Conservation in Theory and Practice
Year: 1950
Type: article
Abstract: More than one speaker, I suspect, has submitted a title under stress, and then when the grim business of preparation began, has opened his dictionary to see exactly what he is to talk about.Following this precedent, I find half a dozen meanings for the word "theory," and more than three times as many for the word "practice."Curiously, I find, too, that when these words are used together, it is in an antagonistic sense.In such instances it is the word "theory" which suffers, for it is used to mean-not a body of principles-but speculation and guesswork.Since our civilization accepts the achievement of power, whether social, political, or economic, as a practical accomplishment and a commendable one, any criticism or opposition can be damned out of hand as being theoretical, speculative, irresponsible, and visionary.Not to be practical in the accepted sense can be a very bad thing indeed, and to call anyone a theorist seems to dispose of him effectively.For a long time those excellent fellows, the sport fishermen, were convinced that poor fishing could be remedied by closed seasons, catch limits, and the breeding of fish in hatcheries.Any suggestion to the contrary was dismissed as theory.Then gradually fishermen began to learn of the importance of clean water as a habitat for fish, of the enormous reproductive power of fish in good environment, and of the extent to which our inland waters have been polluted by sewage, industrial waste, and silt from eroding farm lands.The resulting protest has taken on the character of a minor political earthquake.Sportsmen have mobilized to demand that our rivers and lakes be made clear again.Now this is an expensive request to those who have so long used our streams as open sewers.As a matter of fact they have a reasonable and honorable defense, for the public which has so long tolerated this abuse is as guilty as they and should be made to shoulder part of the burden.But the interesting fact is that in the heat of battle the first defense was to reach for a deadly weapon-the word "theory."The fishermen who demanded an end to pollution were called "theorists," although they include men from all walks of life.It was amusing to see, in the newspapers, a fair cross-section of our population thus labelled, on the bland assumption that if you call a man a "theorist" you are effectively rid of him.Even those who should know better fall for this.I recall a congressman who had considerable respect for science.One day he asked me point blank if it would not be a good thing to prohibit the growing of wheat in the semi-arid country west of the 100th meridian where the Dust-bowl lies.Knowing the mischief which had resulted from this practice, it was a great temptation to say "Yes, of course" and have done with it.But as a scientist I was familiar with the diversity of soils and other conditions in this area.In all honesty, I had to qualify my answer.Unfortunately my host was not a scientist.He was a politician, though an enlightened one.He couldn't be bothered with details, however simply they were
Author: Paul B. Sears
Language: English
Subfield: Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2277361819
