The Incompatibility of Islam and Democracy: How Each is Irrevocably and Diametrically Opposed to the Other
Year: 2010
Type: preprint
Abstract: The notion that democracy, whether western-style or some other arrangement, will be warmly received by any society that has an opportunity to acquire it is controversial. The termination of the Cold War two decades ago provided a great deal of enthusiasm that even countries traditionally resistant to democracy would now endorse it. The defeat of fascism and communism insured that democracy would prosper in a world empty of international predators. The enthusiasm was not entirely misplaced. Much of Eastern Europe and some countries in Latin America either established or enhanced democratic regimes that are being sustained. Some South and East Asian states demonstrated long before the Cold War ended that democracies were not restricted to North America and Western Europe. This paper suggests that democracy, despite its successes and perhaps in part because of them, is being successfully resisted in predominantly Islamic societies. Other indices of democracy such as educational levels, economic development, and overall modernity are also important considerations. We must also recognize that Islam is far from being a monolithic ideology. Some democratic progress has been made in overwhelmingly Islamic countries such as Indonesia and Turkey. However, until or unless Islam undergoes an unprecedented reform there is little realist hope for democracy in the Islamic world. Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, and Judaism have all managed accommodations with democracy. Islam has not and the forces of reform in Islam remain weak and, in many cases, actively persecuted.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Martin Slann
Language: English
Topic: Islamic Studies and History
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2280342972
