A Variational Approach to Perception and Psychophysics
Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis suggests an application of the methods of variational calculus and statistical mechanics to a possible model of perception capable of encompassing both behavioral and neurelectrical phenomena. The central idea of variational calculus is that the behavior of a system can be described as a consequence of an optimality request on some fundamental quantity. In particular, given a system evolving from a state A to a state B, the methods of analytical mechanics allow one to derive its energy and behavior by the knowledge of its Lagrangian function. Indeed, among all the possible patterns that the system could follow during its evolution, the natural one is the one which makes stationary an integral of the Lagrangian function called Action. Thus, in this thesis, changes in sensation will be conceived as patterns in time, and the optimality constraint that they must satisfy will be investigated. Moreover, the energy needed to sustain sensation will be hypotesized to be related to the neurelectric response. In particular, it will be mainly investigated a possible relation between sensation and the response of primary afferent units. After a brief introduction on the mathematical methods needed in the treatise, in the second chapter will be sketched a possible theoretical framework that allows one to apply the concepts of variational calculus to perception and psychophysics. The general idea is to deal with the pattern followed in time by sensation as if it were a motion that can be derived in the context of analytical mechanics as a solution to an Euler-Lagrange equation. In addition, the energy possessed by the motion is posited to be, from a physiological perspective, related to the neurelectric behavior of the system. In the third chapter the model is then formalized and applied to a steady stimulus case. In particular, the psychophysical adaptation phenomenon will be chosen to describe the pattern followed by sensation in time. A depletion of the sensation elicited by a steady stimulus can indeed be seen as a motion from a state A to a state B. A possible Lagrangian function will be derived: a free particle Lagrangian, with a time-varying mass, that appears to be a sufficient (but not necessary) condition to derive the fundamental psychophysical laws while accounting for time-varying features and the measurability of prothetic continua on interval scales. Other fundamental features will then be investigated and tentatively connected with neurophysiological aspects. In particular, the depletion of energy during adaptation suggests a possible connection with neurophysiological aspects like the response of the firing rate in primary afferent units. Hence, in the fourth chapter, a time-featured variation of the Naka-Rushton relation is introduced to characterize neurelectric phenomena. In particular, the pattern followed by the firing rate of primary afferent units is extended to time by the addition of pure spike frequency adaptation and dynamic range adaptation. The resulting model, when the energy is related to the firing rate, allows one to investigate a simplified model that links the response of primary afferent units to the corresponding psychophysical behavior. In particular, sensation appears to be described by an equation capable of switching from a power law to a logarithmic law depending on the signal-to-noise ratio. In addition, changes in sensation are driven by the firing rate, adaptation follows the increasing of the inter-spike-interval, and the system adapts minimizing the total number of action potentials. A test of the preliminary results of the model reveals a good agreement with data taken from literature on the sense of touch, for which the approximation of a straight connection between sensation and the response of primary afferent units holds better than in the other senses. In particular, the psychophysical law and the neurelectrical law of the model appear to have the same exponents. In the fifth chapter some concepts of statistical mechanics are introduced to account for both the limited resolving power of the psychophysical systems and the discreteness of many sensory modalities. In particular, it will be posited that the perceiving system is uncapable of discriminating between different sensations whose neurelectric energies are very close to each other. Moving from this assumption and using the shape of the energy modeled in chapter four some laws of psychophysics will be derived: the Bloch-Charpentier law (or equivalently the Weiss-Lapicque law in the case of irritable tissues), the Ekman law and a general shape for the jnd, the Poulton-Teghtsoonian relation and finally a shape of the Weber fraction capable of accounting for both the decreasing trend at low intensities and the rising portion close to the end of the perceiving range. The latter relation, in particular, will be tested on data taken from literature on the discrimination of sucrose concentration, heaviness, brightness, loudness and skin indentation, revealing a discrete agreement but also some shortcomings. In particular, its minimum appears to anticipate the actual one sistematically, so that the rising portion increases more slowly than the actual data. Finally, in the sixth chapter, the framework developed for steady stimuli will be extended to time-varying stimuli and a preliminary interpretation of the results will be given with a particular focus on some shortcomings and some strength points of the model. Other results or deepenings on the model (like the derivation of Pieron's law for simple reaction time moving from the model's entropy) are given in the Appendixes.
Author: Stefano Noventa
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2287270610
