Hanging in the balance : equity in community-based natural resource management in Asia
Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: RECOFTC Equality versus Fairness"Equity involves getting a 'fair share', not necessarily an equal share.What is regarded as a 'fair share' varies according to different situations (and different cultures)" (Fisher 1989).This definition by Fisher (1989), which is our starting point, draws attention to two related issues.First, the implication is that although there may be differences in the levels of resources or benefits received by different stakeholders, for instance according to their effort or role in a resource management system, if this rate of distribution is perceived as 'fair' then it may be regarded as an equitable arrangement.Second, it suggests that the 'benchmark' for measuring equity needs to be situationally determined to account for social contexts, norms and values.While useful as a starting point, we found this definition needed further elaboration to provide a workable framework for assessing equity in CBNRM.Jacobs (1989) defines two dimensions of equity relating to the substance or outcome of a policy or resource management system, and the process by which actions are formulated and implemented.The outcome refers to the allocation of costs and benefits amongst stakeholders as a result of policy or resource management decisions.This has been called economic equity (Poteete 2004), and also allocative or Economic and Political Equity Who Sets the Benchmark for Equity?If, as suggested by Fisher, we regard equity in relative rather than absolute terms; who decides what is or is not equitable?The case study of the Khasi in Northeast India presented by Kyrham Nongkynrih provides some interesting insights into this question.The exclusion of women from decision making processes at one level may be regarded as fair from the standpoint of tradition in Khasi society, but social change access to productive and high value forests in the terai (the flat southern portion of Nepal) on the basis that these policies create inequity between terai and hill communities.The national government counter argument is that it is better equipped to manage these resources and that the benefits of these forests should be distributed equitably through the country.Bhola however, argues that civil society organizations (CSOs) are in fact better positioned to help communities manage forests successfully through facilitation of more efficient participation and the development of connections with distant user groups.In addition, he suggests that CSOs have the potential to promote decentralization and participatory democracy, to improve livelihoods of the poor and to promote sustainable forest management.In the Philippines, the government has declared CBNRM to be a national strategy.Domingo Bacalla analyzes the policy framework that promotes this approach in terms of how well it achieves equity in access to forest lands.The logging ban, in place since December 2004, limits economic activities to subsistence activities only in forest lands allocated as Community-based Forest Management Areas, and therefore restrict the economic rights over the forest areas of numerous rural and indigenous communities and limits their opportunities to gain commercial benefits.He finds that there have been a number of successful initiatives, but that the policy framework needs to be complemented with more formal involvement by local communities in rule making.In addition, greater support from Local Government Units is needed to ensure higher levels of community participation in community-based forest management, without which disparities in equity may actually be broadened under CBNRM policies.Can Liu performs a statistical analysis on the relationship between poverty and total factor production.By using a two-stage model of stochastic frontier approach, he looks at the productivity of households from three counties in China that have high rates of poverty yet are rich in natural resources.He concludes that the total productivity of rural households has not increased from 1991 to 2001, despite being located adjacent to abundant areas of natural resources.He argues that it is impossible for farmers to escape the poverty trap unless off-farm income is earned to increase total productivity.He further suggests that issues such as market controls, which discourage foreign investment, and land allocation, which causes land fragmentation and neighborly disputes, are leading factors in the inability of peasants to increase productivity.This is leading to increasing inequity between poor farmers in forest rich areas and farmers in other areas of China.In Indonesia, Perhum Perhutani, a state-owned company, has realized that its traditional practices have encouraged the destruction of forests, have been ineffective in terms of soliciting community collaboration and have excluded marginalized groups such as women.Diah Djajanti describes a new program (Managing the Forest with Community), in which Perhum Perhutani employees encourage more equitable community participation, especially among marginalized groups such as women, and introduce benefit sharing processes to create more equitable distribution of resources.Through these practices, the community in this study has seen marked increases in NTFP extraction and incomes.Indeed, the community has also been successful at preserving forests as the incentives to convert plots to agriculture have decreased.Numerous scholars and practitioners have recognized that civil society organizations (CSOs) can play important roles in achieving CBNRM objectives, particularly in societies stratified along ethnic, caste or gendered lines.Harisharan Luitnel examines the crucial role that CSOs play in the Nepali context in promoting equity in CBNRM by implementing positive discrimination for the poor as well as groups marginalized by caste and gender and benefit sharing programs through the Participatory Action and Learning (PAL) process.Through these processes and programs, communities have successfully been organized, overcoming deeply rooted cultural differences.However, Harisharan also cautions that CSOs need to critically reflect on their roles and limitations in promoting equity in CBRNM.CSOs and
Language: English
Subfield: Global and Planetary Change
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: equity, community-based natural resource management, forest governance, Khasi, civil society organizations, participatory democracy, decentralization, sustainable forest management, forest policy, Philippines, Indonesia, economic equity, political equity, forest access, livelihoods of the poor
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2291764102
