Manifest Error: Grounds for Review?
Year: 2012
Type: preprint
Abstract: The nature of appellate review of sentence in a jurisdiction reflects its particular conception of what amounts to fair sentencing and the rule of law. Australian courts of criminal appeal have traditionally adopted a narrow view of their relationship with the lower courts, evidenced by their limited interpretation of the grounds of review and the extent to which they legitimately ‘interfere’ with original sentences. This article examines appeals initiated on the ground that a sentence is either manifestly excessive or inadequate as they apply in Victoria where they are the most commonly argued and successful grounds of appeal. It argues that the present interpretation of this ground is problematic and suggests that, for the sake of transparency and consistency, the ground of manifest error should be recast as an error in principle in its own right, rather than as evidence of some unspecified error.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Authors: Sarah Krasnostein, Arie Freiberg
Institution: Monash University
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2292548997
