Work

Why Do Some Schools Get More and Others Less? An Examination of School-Level Funding in New York City

Year: 2007
Type: preprint
Abstract: In the spring of 2007, the New York City Department of Education announced an ambitious plan to change the way it distributes resources across its more than 1,400 schools. The plan, known as the “Fair Student Funding” initiative, is intended to change funding methods in two ways: first, by allocating money based upon characteristics of the student body that capture differences in the cost of providing appropriate educational services; second, by allocating dollars rather than specific resources, primarily teacher positions, and allowing principals greater discretion in the deployment of those resources. The overarching goal is to improve equity, particularly vertical equity, in the distribution of resources and, ultimately, to improve the efficiency of how resources are used to promote student performance. These reforms will be implemented gradually. For 2007-2008, the new formulae will only be used to distribute a portion of newly available funds, and substantial hold-harmless provisions significantly limit the impact on overall funding. Given this dramatic policy change, it is a particularly good time to examine the current distribution of resources across schools in New York City and to consider what we know about the intradistrict allocation of resources. The purpose is two fold. First, we hope to provide a context for understanding funding reform, both through empirical analyses of funding in New York City and by drawing on the lessons from previous reforms and research. Second, we hope to provide benchmarks against which we can assess the impact of Fair Student Funding in the future, as it is implemented. Before doing so, however, we consider why – and how – the intradistrict allocation of resources matters. We then review previous evidence on the distribution of school resources in New York City and elsewhere, including typical allocation methods and reform proposals. Next, we present new empirical analyses examining the distribution of resources by funding source across schools in New York City. We conclude with a discussion of policy implications.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2293922875
Cites: 25
Cited by: 10
Related to: 9