The Story of Lucas: Environmental Land Use Regulation Between Developers and the Deep Blue Sea
Year: 2005
Type: preprint
Abstract: This background study of the Lucas case focuses on legislative efforts to protect the evocative and productive lands of areas. A starting point is the failed effort in the early 1970s to enact a Federal Land Use Act that would encourage statewide land use planning. The Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA) was in effect a remnant of this larger effort, successful because it isolated opposition by narrowing the regulatory ambit to the popular area. State programs often replicated the CZMA's pattern of isolating opposition by focusing on a relatively narrow area. This strategy, however, ran two risks: first, the environmental risk that a truncated coastal zone would miss important influences outside that zone; and second, the jurisprudential risk that narrowly drawn laws would be caught in an evolving jurisprudence, fueled by an increasingly vocal property rights movement. Both risks became clear in California's pioneering and aggressive program, but the issues came to a head not in California but in South Carolina, as this state (following environmental theories developed in neighboring North Carolina) attempted to orchestrate a retreat from beachfront development. South Carolina's efforts ran into David Lucas' claim that the new regulations made his beachfront property lose all economic value. When the Supreme Court accepted this theory, the decision galvanized property rights proponents but also set off a wave of criticism. Subsequent events have initiated some reconsideration of traditional takings theories, since the decision does not fit well into standard political, economic or fairness theories of takings. The author concludes that takings jurisprudence is best understood as part of the management of regulatory transitions.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Carol M. Rose
Institution: University of Arizona
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2298845043
