Year: 2012
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Water management is a critical issue throughout the world because when water is scarce it leads to droughts, and when excessive it leads to floods, particularly in countries with high variability in rainfall, exacerbated further by the effects of climate change. Storing rainfall in farm dams can help mitigate the effects of droughts and floods but only if managed sustainably, which is generally not the case world-wide. Hence, sustainable storage of surface water in farm dams is an area requiring urgent attention. In Australia, where there are estimates of at least 735,000 farm dams, the sustainable management of agricultural surface water storage presents a significant dual-extreme problem for policy and practice: in times of drought, there is an incentive to store more water than entitled leading to an unfair sharing of limited surface water resources between farmers, communities and the environment; and, in times of flood, an unsafe structure can cause catastrophic consequences downstream.%%%%This study aims to address the problem of unsustainably managed farm dams through application of Oliver’s (1991) framework integrating resource dependence and institutional theories to explain farmers’ resistance to institutional pressure to manage their dams in a sustainable way. The study employs a quantitative survey design in order to compare sustainable farm dam management response in four states across Australia representing diverse sustainable farm dam management institutional environments: South Australia, New South Wales, Victoria and Tasmania. Sampling from these test states resulted in telephone survey data collected from 404 participants.%%%%Results from multiple regression analyses suggest that the institutional antecedents of context, control, content, constituents, and cause predict farmers’ compliance with or resistance to pressure to manage farm dams in a sustainable way. More specifically, where there is uncertainty, disconnectedness, or a lack of voluntary diffusion, sustainable farm dam management strategies will need to be tailored differently from environments where pressures provide certainty and control over farm dam decisions and are consistent with farm goals. Institutional actors such as industry bodies, community groups and banks are beneficial and can often help drive an acquiescent response to pressure in strong institutional environments where legal coercion to manage dams sustainably is highly resisted. Reputational and economic incentives for good farm dam management will encourage low resistance to pressures for sustainable behaviour independent of the strength of the institutional environment of the farmer.%%%%The study makes three main contributions. Firstly, it provides in-depth understanding of a complex water storage management problem in critical need of research through broad-scale empirical insight. Secondly, it advances Oliver’s (1991) theoretical framework as a lens for investigating the institutional foundations of sustainable responses to problems of water resource management more…
Author: Joanne L. Tingey-Holyoak
Language: English
Subfield: Water Science and Technology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2302273045
