Detecting cooked bone in the archaeological record : a study of the thermal stability and deterioration of bone collagen
Year: 2006
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Cooked bone must account for a large proportion of the skeletal finds from archaeological sites yet it is still not possible to detect cooked bone unless it has become charred.The reason for this is that mild heating (80°C, one hour), such as is usual in cooking, does not lead to detectable changes in any biochemical parameter yet measured.The aim of thesis was to develop a technique which could detect this level of heat damage.This was attempted by analysing the collagen component of heated bone with microscopy and calorimetry.Differential scanning calorimetry was only able to detect catastrophic damage which occurred after extensive heating (six hours at 100°C or > 145°C).However using transmission electron microscopy it was possible to visualize heat-damage at the level of the collagen fibril after very mild heat treatment.The approach was tested on modern, forensic and archaeological material.Buried bone that had not been cooked showed some alteration similar to that caused by cooking, nevertheless paired cooked and uncooked bones could always be distinguished.Analysis of modern human material with different ages-at-death showed an apparent age-related stability; the collagen fibrils from older individuals were more resistant to thermal alteration and swelling in acid.This was also observed, more dramatically, in artificially cross-linked bone collagen.Conversely bones buried in acidic soils for a short period showed a rapid fragmentation of the collagen fibrils.This analysis has given an insight into the very early stages of collagen collapse within bone and has shown that even when protected by mineral, it is prone to damage.Degradation of bone collagen appears to be governed by the integrity of the collagen fibril and if viewed in this way can help to explain why bone collagen can remain intact far into the archaeological record, why severely diagenetically altered bone can yield undamaged collagen molecules and why bone collagen is such a reliable material for isotopic dietary analysis and 14C dating.
Author: Hannah E. C Koon
Language: English
Subfield: Archeology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2309610086
