Year: 2012
Type: article
Abstract: In her thoughtful article, "Is there an "after" of identity" Linda Alcoff identifies one of the primary concerns that motivates my book, After Identity: Rethinking Race, Sex and Gender: "Racist extremists…overplay the importance of identity, misconstrue the political meaning of identity, collapse national and ethnic identities, and target specific identities as inevitable obstacles to harmony and national prosperity."Given the ills to which identities have given rise, the aim of the book is to reconsider what they are and whether their influence exceeds their brief.Alcoff raises questions about After Identity's approach, however, as do Lauren Barthold and Naomi Zack in their own thoughtful responses to the book.Barthold questions the way its equation of texts and people is meant to work; Zack is concerned about what she sees as a conflation of hermeneutic and ethical considerations; Alcoff thinks the book neglects the importance of embodied experiences; and, in a related criticism, Barthold thinks it neglects what she calls subjective identity essences.In what follows, I would like to try to respond to all these objections.In doing so, I hope also to provide a somewhat different perspective on identity than the one Laurie Shrage offers in her article.I begin with a review of the hermeneutic account that provides the background to the book.Traditionally, hermeneutic theories are concerned with the understanding and interpretation of texts and conceive of this understanding and interpretation in terms of the hermeneutic circle of part and whole: we understand the meaning of a part of a text in terms of our understanding of the whole and we understand the whole of a text in terms of our understanding of its parts.If we can understand Shakespeare's King Lear as a tragedy it is because of the way we understand the meanings of its
Author: Georgia Warnke
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2310667215
