Work

Live Events and Schizophrenic Episodes

Year: 1985
Type: editorial
Abstract: Stressful events have been widely accepted as a cause of a variety of psychiatric disorders, including affective disorders, most neuroses and schizophrenia.In the first two instances, the published data are extensive (see reviews by Lloyd, 1980;Paykel, 1978) yet the findings are far from conclusive (Tennant, 1983).In the case of schizophrenia, the empirical evidence is indeed scant (reviews by Dohrenwend and Egri, 1981; Day, 1981;Rabkin, 1980), but in the last few years a little more empirical evidence has emerged from Leff and his colleagues in London, which has not been critically reviewed.The present review therefore reassesses the evidence that life event stress may play a causal role in the onset or relapse of schizophrenic episodes.Most of these studies are methodologically unsound.The major limitations include the following: 1. Life event inventories have been most widely used, and these usually lack sensitivity in definition of items, include a limited number of items, and make no provision for excluding those events which may be caused by illness or the prodromata of illness (i.e. the events are not independent of illness) and as discussed in several reviews (e.g.Sarason et al., 1975; Jenkins et a/., 1979; Tennant et a/., 1981).2. Problems in recall of events, both the progressive fall off of recall with the passage of time (which, it is hoped, will affect cases and controls equally) and 'effort after meaning', which will be most marked in studies using normal controls as a comparison group.3. Problems in defining 'onset' of illness: many studies have equated the hospitalisation of the subject to the date of onset, so these studies can only assess, in fact, whether life events precipitated hospitalisation in schizophrenics rather than the disorder itself.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2150872559
Cites: 24
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9