Year: 2012
Type: article
Abstract: We appreciate Dr Xue and colleagues’ interest in our study [1] and their valuable comments. We should like to clarify several important points that they raised. First, as Xue et al. pointed out, we did not record the actual intubation time. However, we believe it unlikely that this time accounts for the haemodynamic differences we observed. Firstly, another group of investigators demonstrated that the intubation times taken by experienced anaesthetists did not differ between the Airway Scope and the Macintosh laryngoscope [2]. Secondly, we excluded cases where the intubation time exceeded 40 s. Thirdly, all intubations were performed by a single, board-certified anaesthetist with considerable experience in both techniques and all the intubations were successful on the first attempt. Regarding the differences in the forces applied to the pharynx by the two airway devices, we thank Xue and colleagues for identifying a manikin study that lends further support to our contention that the Airway Scope exerts less force than the Macintosh laryngoscope. Xue et al. raise an interesting point that the stimulation produced by passing the tube into the trachea may be stronger than that produced by the application of the airway device. We also believe that this may explain why haemodynamic responses to the Airway Scope and the Macintosh laryngoscope were similar in hypertensive patients. We would also point out that, in contrast to the three references Xue et al. cited, other studies [2–5] have demonstrated that the avoidance of direct laryngoscopy led to less haemodynamic stress responses to tracheal intubation. Tracheal intubation using the Airway Scope [2] and the Lightwand [3] attenuated all haemodynamic stress responses compared with the Macintosh laryngoscope. In addition, the Airtraq® [4] and the StyletScope (NihonKohden Corp., Tokyo, Japan) [5] also attenuated the heart rate increase immediately after tracheal intubation compared with the Macintosh laryngoscope. Therefore, whether the avoidance of direct laryngoscopy attenuates haemodynamic stress responses to tracheal intubation appears to be controversial. Finally, Xue and colleagues are correct in that we did not describe the end-tidal sevoflurane concentration during anaesthesia induction. However, we believe the end-tidal sevoflurane concentrations were sufficiently uniform among our patients, because we standardised the anaesthesia induction technique using the same vaporiser settings and fresh gas flows, as well as the time from induction to tracheal intubation.
Source: Anaesthesia
Authors: Y. Koyama, M. Nishihama, G. Inagawa, Y. Kamiya, T. Miki, R. Kurihara, T. Goto
Institution: Yokohama City University
Language: English
Subfield: Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2317766554
