Year: 1996
Type: article
Abstract: This is a rich, varied, interesting volume, one of the best in a fine series.A quick survey of its contents page should whet the appetite of anyone interested in current philosophy of religion: Tooley and Rowe offer versions of the argument from evil, while Alston and Van Inwagen counter that humans are not in the right epistemic position to judge such arguments sound.Marilyn Adams explores the non-moral aspect of the concept of sin, and William Mann the problems moral dilemmas pose for theistic ethical theory (introducing en route the intriguing concept of a moral monolemma).Chisholm defends the soul's simplicity, Hoffman and Rosenkrantz its intelligibility.Audi, Gale and Quinn tackle religious epistemology.Plantinga discusses his views of warrant and the prospects for natural theology.Fischer treats Ockllamism, Robert M. Adams offers a new argument against middle knowledge, and Thomas Flint offers one for it.Stump, Kretzmann and Wierenga debate whether the doctrine of divine timelessness can on its own reconcile human freedom with the existence of divinely revealed prophecies and the past truth of claims about what God timelessly knows.Freddoso argues that God must not only conserve creatures' existence but actively "concur" with their actions, while McCann and Kvanvig urge that mere conservation is enough to entail occasionalism (i.e. that there are no causally efficacious creaturely actions with which to concur).Wolterstorff takes on divine simplicity.Menzel gives an account of divine ideas and God's precreative foreknowledge.Earl Conee discusses the claim that God is able to do literally anything, possible or not.And Edward Zalta and Paul Oppenheimer give a new broadly Meinongian analysis of the ontological argument.The papers all are of high quality, and the paperback price of $22.00 for more than 600 pages of such work fits the book for a philosophical Consumer Reports' Best Buy list.This book's sheer size precludes saying anything worthwhile about all or even most of the papers.So I will use my space to talk about a few that especially interested me.
Source: Faith and Philosophy
Authors: Brian Leftow, The Society of Christian Philosophers
Institution: Fordham University
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2320813146
