Year: 1999
Type: article
Abstract: This is the third edition of a textbook purporting to portray the "Maudsley approach" to psychiatry.The textbook was first published in 1979 with the second edition in 1985.The Maudsley is, of course, the Institute of Psychiatry and the Bethlem Royal and Maudsley Hospitals in London.It is one of the leading psychiatric research and clinical centers in the world and is important as a training site, not only for British psychiatrists but for those throughout much of the former outreaches of the British colonial empire.Because of the geographic scope of the Institute, one must take great notice of the importance and influence of this volume.The Institute itself was recognized in 1993 by Science Watch as being the most widely cited psychiatric research center in the world.The second edition, published in the mid 1980s, added several new subjects (adolescence, atypical psychosis, selfdestructive behavior, and disorders of women).New topics are also covered in this late 1990s, third edition of the volume.This edition includes chapters on the neuroscientific approach to psychiatry and presents some material on health services research.The Maudsley approach is a blend of European phenomenology and British empiricism.What the editors make clear is that they want to combine their old traditions with the new international psychiatry, keeping a proper mix of theory and practice.Another goal, directly stated, is to offer an alternative to American psychiatry, which the senior editor believes is dominated by the pharmaceutical industry and the American Psychiatric Association.I was immediately impressed with the high quality of the contributions and the remarkable similarity of the thinking and approach that I had experienced as a registrar (resident) at the Maudsley in 1970.The list of contributors has changed through the years and has expanded with subsequent editions, but the general tenets are quite enduring.The writing retains the elegance and clarity that the monographs and articles emanating from this institution have demonstrated for decades.In most reviews of textbooks, it is asserted that there is an unevenness to the work because of the multiplicity of authors.This textbook has less unevenness than most such volumes.These authors are largely a distinguished group; several are department chairs.Many are former colleagues from my experience at the Maudsley.The organization is in 4 parts: general principles, clinical disorders, psychiatry in special settings, and principles of treatment.The most interesting section to me was the first, particularly the chapters on "Mental State and States of Mind" by Paul
Author: Richard C. Shelton
Language: English
Topic: Mental Health and Psychiatry
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2325822149
