Year: 1999
Type: article
Abstract: Thank you for the opportunity to reply to these letters. As I indicated in my editorial, strong emotions are roused by discussions on this topic. I stand by my views — and lest anyone think otherwise, let me make it clear that I am not speaking from some ‘ivory tower’. I single handedly provided the general anaesthetic service to our community dental service for some 12 years and practised in dental surgeries as well. I have never doubted that there will always be a residual need for general anaesthesia to be provided. At issue is the setting and personnel and these are the critical areas which we need to address. I am well aware of the public health issues, the numbers involved and the needs of children, but this sort of emotional blackmail is always employed when change is envisaged. Comment is focused very largely on children, but I do not underestimate the needs of adults. I acknowledge the skills, commitment and safety record of many practitioners who have provided an excellent service for many years in this difficult area, often in inadequate premises. I am also sure that many dental surgeons do indeed dissuade patients from seeking general anaesthesia and I also know perfectly well the problem of young children with grossly carious dentition. That is precisely the point that needs to be made. General anaesthesia needs to be restricted to those cases where it is genuinely indicated, and the total number required should then fall to a level at which alternative provision can be made, rather than working in a multitude of isolated sites. That there are many conscientious and skilled practitioners working successfully in this field is not in doubt, but every tragedy brings disrepute to the profession. The mantle of paternalism is gone forever, and it is sad but true that the majority is tarred with the same brush as the minority. The ramifications of recent high-profile cases are part of this process, which we cannot avoid or evade. It is my view that it is better to lead change than have change imposed upon us. I do not underestimate the difficulties or the costs involved in such a change in practice, but someone somewhere has to say ‘enough’. Unless this is done, the situation will persist. We must have the courage to say that the time for action is now. The decision to make the change is essentially political, since that is the source of funding. Should the political will not be there, we should at least make our professional views clear. I have made mine clear, as has the Royal College of Anaesthetists via its Dental Committee. The Royal College of Anaesthetists' Dental Committee is in favour of safe dental anaesthesia, wherever it is conducted, but in our view it should not be conducted on isolated sites. It is also our view, and that of the General Dental Council, that anaesthesia should be conducted by trained specialists who are on the Specialist Register of the General Medical Council. Is this unreasonable? I must on behalf of the Royal College of Anaesthetists refute the question that it has failed in its charter obligation to protect the public. The College has control only over training and consultant appointments, and not over individual practice in dental surgeries. The service is indeed underfunded and that has been pointed out on many occasions; the available fees are so low that it is unlikely to attract skilled consultant anaesthetists. The College can only advise but has no actual power. The power to limit the activities of individual practitioners lies with the General Medical Council, which has never addressed this area of practice. The General Dental Council has now acted and its advice is plain: only specialists should provide anaesthesia in dental surgeries. It is indeed a pity that the first news of the changes in dental anaesthesia came via the media, but this followed the General Dental Council's decision and was not in the control of the College or the Association. There had been extensive consultation among the profession and a consensus view emerged, which I support. If we can reduce the number of general anaesthetics given to those clinically indicated, we would have the staff and facilities to cope. Since the General Dental Council's ruling, the number of dental general anaesthetics is reported to have fallen steeply. I have not heard of a corresponding leap in hospital waiting lists, so presumably alternative treatment is now taking place. Dr Williams misunderstands me. I do not ‘airily dismiss’ any group of patients, but we have to be realistic. I am in favour of safe dental anaesthesia wherever it is conducted. Death after dental anaesthesia is indeed rare; the public expectation is that it should be avoidable and that the provision of anaesthesia on isolated sites is no longer acceptable. Dental anaesthesia has a long history but it is time for change. Dr Clewett makes some valid points, but I refute the suggestion that my editorial was economical with the truth. I was careful not to allude to the publications by Coplans and Curson, as both of these relate to conditions before the Poswillo report. It is a sad fact that deaths continue to occur — indeed I have heard of a death in a dental surgery which has occurred since the editorial was published. I agree with much of what Dr Webb writes, but would assure him that we are not ‘joining a bandwagon’, nor just ‘following hype’. He is right in his assertion that the time for action was years ago, but the fact that nothing has happened is largely the fault of the specialty. For too long, anaesthetists have been willing to preserve the status quo and continue to provide a service, with only occasional mutterings. Few have been prepared to stand up and say ‘Enough — we cannot continue like this’. We have continued to provide the service, in the interests of patients, and our own incomes. Funding is at the heart of the problem. Adequate funding and a proper financial return would (I hope) result in a better quality of service. The present system is cheap for the NHS, and relies on goodwill for little financial reward, but so long as we do it why should the government increase funding? This may be unpalatable, but it is true. It is not the function of the DEB to insist on the use of particular anaesthetic agents; they simply pay out for procedures performed. They have no interest in safety, merely in keeping costs down. They are more likely to insist on halothane, which I do not think many would find acceptable. The real answer, as I wrote in my editorial, is for anaesthetists to force change. I have heard and understand the special pleadings for various groups. I sympathise with them and agree that we must provide a service for them, but in safety. Redirection of resources would enable this service to be provided, but we have to force the issue. I echo Dr Clewett's sentiments regarding the need for partnership between Health Authorities, Trusts and the professions. If we can achieve this we really will take a huge stride in improving safety, but so long as we continue to work in the present system there is no incentive for change. I used to provide general anaesthetics for the community dental service. Following Poswillo, I indicated that I would resign if improvements were not forthcoming. They were not. I resigned, and could not be replaced until the service was located on a hospital site, where we now provide an anaesthetic service under the auspices of the local Department of Anaesthesia, including training for junior anaesthetists. So long as we soldier on, the present system will persist. Persuasion has failed. It is time for action.
Source: Anaesthesia
Author: D. P. Cartwright
Language: Kazakh
Subfield: Oral Surgery
Field: Dentistry
Domain: Health Sciences
Keyword: dental anesthesia
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2331433374
