Year: 2010
Type: article
Abstract: We thank Drs Butchart and Young for their interesting comments on our paper [1], and welcome the opportunity to respond to these comments. We agree with the authors that there is a learning curve with regard to the acquisition of skills with all laryngoscopes, and a decay curve with regard to loss of skills over time. However, these skills appear to be acquired more quickly, and lost less quickly, at least with the Airtraq laryngoscope, when compared with the Macintosh laryngoscope [2, 3]. With regard to our study, the authors are correct in that, while the participants used the devices in random order, the order in which the scenarios were attempted was not randomised. Tracheal intubation attempts with each device were first performed in the easy laryngoscopy scenario, followed by the difficult laryngoscopy scenario. Therefore, it is possible that a learning effect was seen when using the Glidescope laryngoscope. However, this was not seen when testing the other videolaryngoscopes, namely the C-MAC and Airtraq laryngoscopes. We agree that there may be advantages to using videolaryngoscopes that incorporate the Macintosh laryngoscope blade, given its familiarity to anaesthetists, and our results in this study do provide some support for that premise [1]. However, these findings need to be replicated in clinical studies, both of easy and predicted difficult laryngoscopy. In addition, it must be remembered that other videolaryngoscopes that incorporate novel blade curvatures and structures, particularly the Airtraq [4–6] and Pentax laryngoscopes [7–9], have performed well in clinical studies of both easy and difficult laryngoscopy, and hold significant promise as alternatives or backup devices to the Macintosh laryngoscope. We are not aware of the Venner AP Advance laryngoscope, and could find no published data regarding this device. Ultimately, we believe that anaesthetists should be expert in the use of more than one type of laryngoscope, and should not limit themselves to the use of laryngoscopes based on the Macintosh blade. The optimal ‘secondary’ laryngoscope (or ‘primary’ laryngoscope, for that matter) that anaesthetists should use will depend on several issues, and remains an active area of investigation. No external funding and no competing interests declared. Previously posted at the Anaesthesia Correspondence website: http://www.anaesthesiacorrespondence.com.
Source: Anaesthesia
Authors: J. McElwain, J. G. Laffey
Institution: Ollscoil na Gaillimhe – University of Galway
Language: English
Subfield: Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2331827914
