Work

Signals or Noise?: The Influence of Judicial Ideology and Public Opinion on Supreme Court Affirmances

Year: 2015
Type: preprint
Abstract: The tension between democratic values and the practice of judicial review remains an enduring problem in American political theory. Political science research showing consistency between public mood and Supreme Court decision-making has provided important empirical evidence that bears on this normative dilemma. This body of evidence has expanded rapidly in recent years as scholars have focused their attention on cases which result in reversals of lower court decisions. However, we argue that excluding affirmances from analyses of judicial behavior may bias estimates of the effects of public opinion on judicial behavior. Moreover, the remaining set of decisions — those affirming lower court rulings — are systematically related to justices’ attitudes and public opinion, albeit in ways that are different from reversals. We test these expectations in a series of dynamics models of the volume of Supreme Court liberalism from 1956 through 2009, finding support for our theoretical expectations.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2336807514
Cites: 21
Cited by:
Related to: 10