Work

Taking a Good Look at the Bad Man’s Point of View

Year: 1981
Type: article
Abstract: In 1897, Oliver Wendell Holmes addressed an audience at the Boston University Law School, telling them, "If you want to know the law and nothing else, you must look at it as a bad man, who cares only for the material consequences which such knowledge enables him to predict..... " 1 Holmes continued by claiming that from the bad man's point of view it can be seen that law consists of "prophecies of what the courts will do in fact, and nothing more pretentious."12 Holmes's paper has been enormously influential in the development of twentieth-century jurisprudence, causing jurists to react to his views in extreme ways.His views laid the foundation for the school of jurisprudence known as American Legal Realism, which maintains that a concern for law is primarily, or even solely, a concern for predicting judicial decisions.3 Legal realism has survived as the accepted legal theory within the American legal profession for much of this century, and law school faculties largely still comprise people who believe that little more needs to be said about what law is than what can be found in Holmes's The Path of the Law.Reactions against realism have been equally strong and extreme, leading generally insightful philosophers to believe that it can easily be dismissed.4 As one might suspect, neither of these reactions can be fully justified.A sympathetic reading of The Path of the Law reveals that Holmes's approach to legal theory makes a significant contribution to our understanding of law.This contribution, however, is less significant than Holmes's followers have thought.As I argue below, realism cannot provide the complete answer to the question, "What is law?"A sympathetic but critical examination of Holmes's theory demont Visiting Assistant
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W234392820
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 5
Related to: 10