Work

John Locke on Toleration, (In)civility, and the Quest for Concord

Year: 2012
Type: preprint
Abstract: Contemporary popular and scholarly debates reflect a growing dissatisfaction with the concept of “toleration” as too permissive towards religious hatreds and their expression among individuals and hence as inattentive to the attitudinal supports needed to sustain religious diversity. Lockean toleration in particular is criticized as too “thin” and, consequently, exclusive. Yet these criticisms ignore the central role in the development of Locke’s thought played by concerns about the existence and expression of such negative attitudes in religious disagreement as evidenced by his consistent preoccupation with the concept of “civility.” When taken into account, one discovers in Locke an understanding of toleration as a kind of concordia — a positive ideal of communion secured by affective bonds of charity and mutual respect — that is far from the grudging permission of difference with which he is often associated. Yet re-interpreting the exclusivity of his toleration in this light has worrying implications for his critics, who likewise share a preference for concord as an approach to difference. It demonstrates that this ideal, though attractive, can be more exclusive than the “mere” toleration of other early modern thinkers.
Institution: Yale University
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2346687192
Cites: 21
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9