Inside of the Creative Mind: Unravelling the Neurocognitive Mechanisms of Musical Creativity
Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Creativity emerges from the individual or collective intellect in order to unfold the conundrum of life and give rise to meaningful deliberations for the attainment of a flourishing life. More specifically, creativity is commonly defined, within the framework of psychology, as a creative act or product that shall fulfill two main criteria: (i) it shall be novel (i.e. original and unexpected) and (ii) qualified judges shall agree upon its valuable contribution to the field. The cognitive science approach to creativity investigates the intellectual processes and representations concerned with the creative thinking. The methodologies of cognitive science, derived from the technological advancements of the past sixty years, have begun to adopt a more definitive and systemic perspective. Neuroscience has emerged, under this context, as the scientific study dedicated to explore the biological substrates of the nervous system, by utilizing a multitude of techniques such as neuroimaging. Cognitive neuroscience, in particular, studies the neural correlates of mental processes and it constitutes the central approach here adopted to study musical creativity. The primary goal of this thesis was thus to investigate the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying musical creativity. Functional magnetic resonance imaging was used to measure brain activity in thirty nine professional pianists and musical improvisation was employed as the ecologically valid behavioral model that could most accurately represent creative musical performance. Study I sought to investigate the specific neurocognitive effects derived from expertise in musical improvisation. A natural question that arises is whether extensive improvisational musical training may induce neuroplasticity in the brain. Many of the observed correlates of general musical training reflect not only acquisition of highly specific sensorimotor skills but also cognitive abilities required for various aspects of musical expertise. However, no study has previously focused on the effects of training musical improvisation. The results revealed a significant negative association between improvisational training and activity in a number of cortical regions in the right hemisphere. Also, improvisational training was specifically associated with functional connectivity during musical improvisation, using the premotor and prefrontal regions (previously reported to be involved during extemporization) as seed regions and controlling for age and conventional piano practice. More experienced improvisers showed higher functional connectivity during improvisation between prefrontal, premotor, and motor regions of the frontal lobe. Furthermore, the results were shown not be confounded by more experienced improvisers producing more complex improvisations. Study II explored the contribution of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) in creative cognition. Different neuroimaging studies have shown so far seemingly paradoxical results regarding the implications of the DLPFC in creative functioning. On one hand, DLPFC has been argued to exert active control over free generative tasks by inhibiting habitual responses, thus enabling more original output; on the other hand, a deactivation and concomitant decrease in monitoring and focused attention has been suggested to facilitate more spontaneous associations and novel insights. Here, the study highlights that creative cognition can be implemented in different ways given different circumstances. Two categories of behavioral conditions were specified in the experimental design to convey constraints either on the musical structure (set of pitches) or on the emotional expression (happiness or fear) of the improvisations. The results confirmed higher activity in the right DLPFC, as well as in the parietal lobe and right dorsal premotor cortex, when contrasting structural conditions with emotional conditions. These results suggest higher attentional effort and cognitive control when the participants had to conform to the structural constraints. Conversely, deactivations were identified for the emotional constraints in the same regions, plus other regions explicitly contributing to emotion processing. In addition, DLPFC was found functionally connected with the frontoparietal network as well as the cerebellum during structural conditions and to various regions comprising the default network during emotional conditions.
Author: Ana Lúısa Pinho
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: musical creativity, musical improvisation, neuroplasticity, functional connectivity, dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, creative cognition, cognitive control, working memory, executive function, professional pianists, right hemisphere, musicianship, neural correlates of creativity, cognitive flexibility
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2396531039
