Work

Exploring doctoral students' theory choices in education.

Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The use of theory, regarded as a set of structured lenses or frameworks through which \nphenomena can be systematically analysed or explained (Klette, 2012; Johnson & \nChristensen, 2007), and deemed central to the entire research process, is not without \ncontention. Contentious issues relate to theory as occupying a nebulous position due to \nits borrowing from the natural sciences for academic legitimacy, and an inherent \nhegemony that entrenches the status quo (Thomas, 1997; Carr; 2006). Given the link \nbetween knowledge production and theory, and that locating a theoretical framework \nforms a major part of doctoral students’ deliberations, the study sought to explore and \nunderstand the process by which doctoral students chose their theories for their doctoral \nresearch. \nA review of the academic literature provided the historical and definitional aspects of \ntheory, some of the contestations about the meanings and uses of theory, and an \nevaluation of issues as they pertained to particular developments within tertiary education \nand postgraduate knowledge generation. Although the social sciences have a diverse \narray of theories to choose from, the literature did not specifically reveal how doctoral \nstudents choose theories. Against this background, this qualitative study, which initially \nadopted an interpretivist case study approach incorporating purposive sampling, was \nlocated at the Faculty of Education at a university in South Africa and focused on five \ndoctoral students who completed their doctoral theses in Education, in the period 2006 to 2011. The study asked the key questions, how do doctoral students choose their focal \ntheories for their study, and why do they do so? \nTo explore doctoral students’ theory choices, the study drew on the salient features of two \ndominant psychological and cognitive theories, viz., the Information Processing \nApproach and Prospect Theory (Beresford & Sloper, 2008; Payne & Bettman, 2004). \nThe emergent data suggested that for the students in this study, factors like academic \ncontext, sociocultural background, intuition, worldviews and knowledge influenced their \ntheory choices. However, several deeper issues emerged which the psychological and cognitive theories of decision-making were inadequate in addressing, particularly issues \nof power, and the dichotomies of east/west, north/south influences on knowledge \ngeneration. Due to the lack of criticality, and the inability of these models to provide a \ndeeper analysis for the why question, the study motivated for the shift to a critical stance, \nunderpinned by the Decolonial Turn, which included an array of positions that viewed \ncoloniality as the problem confronting the modern world (Maldonado-Torres, 2011). The \nliterature on Said’s Postcolonial theoretical views on Orientlalism, Gayatri Spivak on the \nsubaltern, Southern Theory by Connell, and Decolonial Theory by Quijano, Mignolo and \nGrosfoguel was reviewed, and decolonial theory was used to analyse the data from a \ncritical stance. It is suggested that while insertions from the North and West may \ncontinue to determine particular theoretical inclinations and choices of theory on the part \nof doctoral students in the periphery, an epistemic shift is occurring in the South. This is \nsupported by the observations from the data that, participants tended toward critical, \nfeminist, gender, postcolonial and postmodern theoretical underpinnings, were conscious \nof the impingement of West/Eurocentricism on their choices and knowledge production, \nand open to alternate knowledge frameworks. Finally, the concept of epistemic \ndissonance is proposed as necessary to delink from the status quo, suggesting it as a \nmeans to confront our assumptions about culture and history, and re-conceptualize our \nresearch in the context of sensitivity to difference, and facilitate a change in \nconsciousness of students towards disrupting particular epistemic gridlocks on theory \nchoices.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2400044938
Cites: 168
Cited by: 5
Related to: 10