Year: 2003
Type: editorial
Abstract: The Royal College of Anaesthetists' Patient Information Project came to an end earlier this year with the publication of a book [1] and a series of patient information leaflets, generated jointly with the Association of Anaesthetists [2]. Writing patient information is difficult, not least because both the process of writing and the end result throw the nature of the doctor–patient relationship into focus. Patient information materials have a number of functions. First, and most obviously, they convey the facts which patients need to understand about the care that is proposed for them. But preparing information materials is not simply about doctors setting down the facts as they see them on paper. Doctors sometimes need to be reminded that words do not simply convey facts; they evoke feelings too. Although patient information is designed to provide information, the emotional effect that some words have on some people cannot be ignored. Second, information allows choice. We know that many more patients want to be informed about their treatment than want to make choices about that treatment [3], but choice is impossible without information. Third, information is required to support the process of granting and obtaining consent [4]. However, patient information has two other functions, akin to side-effects, which like all side-effects may be desirable or undesirable depending on one's point of view. Leaflets whose ‘official’ purpose is to inform patients are frequently used to further professional agendas. As we worked our way through the leaflets which the College amassed, we found instances of anaesthetists (and others) using patient information to ‘blow their own trumpet’ in the College's collection. Information can also act as a lever for change. Knowledge is power, and informing patients also makes them more powerful. This can be useful to us as it can inspire patients to take a more active and responsible role in their care − for instance, if patients understand the effects of smoking they may be more likely to abstain pre-operatively − but also makes some doctors uneasy. If patients have greater knowledge and understanding of what goes on, might they start questioning what we are doing? Whether this is empowerment or subversion depends entirely on your point of view. Good patient information is defined by the following features [5]. It describes what will happen, explains why this is so, and gives various treatment options with their relative risks and benefits. Some believe that ideally the information given should be supported with references to the sources used, akin to a scientific paper [6]. It must be available wherever and whenever it is needed (this practical issue is important but is not dealt with further here) and, finally, it should be written with patients. Not by patients alone, nor by doctors with patients in mind, but by both in partnership. The document from the College had fairly modest origins, being conceived initially as a successor to the Audit Recipe Book ‘Raising the Standard’[7]. As time went on it became clear that the whole issue of patient information was rapidly becoming a hot topic and that the College was attracting considerable attention in political and policymaking circles. The decision was taken to make the whole process of production ‘patient-centred’. But what is a ‘patient’ in this context? Clearly most of the ‘ordinary’ patients we come across could not work on such a project. That is not to say that they would be incapable, but that their contribution will be limited to their own experiences, some of which may not be typical. ‘Patients’ can also be recruited from more specialised patient interest groups. These are usually devoted to a particular disease or condition − breast cancer or incontinence, for instance. These individuals often have, or have had, the condition in question, are frequently very knowledgeable about it and very effective both in supporting others and lobbying for better services for that particular group. However, there is, to my knowledge, no group devoted to patients who undergo or have undergone anaesthesia. Instead, the College called upon what is known as patient representatives. These individuals are highly motivated and well educated and see themselves mainly as representing patients' interests in general, albeit within specific contexts such as anaesthesia. Their guiding belief is to uphold patients' autonomy, but this can be broken down into a number of principles to guide everyday practice. These are discussed more fully in a chapter on the patient's perspective [8] but include equity, respect, shared decision-making and safety. Most doctors already subscribe to the concept of patients' autonomy, and would not fundamentally question the other principles. But what matters is where exactly the boundary lines are drawn. Nowhere is this territorial dispute more apparent than in the related issues of risk and safety. Anaesthesia is perceived by patients as especially risky; they are often more afraid of the anaesthetic than the surgery it enables. But is anaesthesia really risky? It is certainly different in many ways from other branches of clinical medicine. Its working environment has more in common with other high-technology industries such as aviation or nuclear power. These are characterised by high dynamism, uncertainty, time pressure, ill-formed problems, complex human–machine interactions and risk [9]. (As a description of the complexities of what anaesthetists do, this sounds much more impressive, and to my mind is more accurate, than ‘I put people to sleep for their operations and wake them up at the end’). Furthermore, psychologists have found that risks which are poorly understood, unwillingly undergone and whose consequences, although possibly rare, are serious, immediate and permanent, are feared more than others [10]. Anaesthesia is often unwillingly undergone, and its most severe complications, though rare, are immediate, permanent and untreatable. So patients' perceptions are valid − anaesthesia is risky. But I think that this perception of riskiness on the patient's part is complemented by anaesthetists' cultural preoccupation with safety, which has always seemed much more intense than most other specialties and which I believe shapes their thinking maybe more than they realise. Risks can be communicated by words, numbers and visual methods either alone or in combination [11]. Many of the leaflets that were read and evaluated during the course of the project featured specific sections devoted to safety and risk, but it soon became clear that these issues coloured the writing of the text throughout the rest of the leaflet, too. Take for example this extract from the Association's 1997 leaflet ‘Anaesthesia and anaesthetists’, a ground-breaking development in its time [12]. The simple question ‘What happens once I am asleep?’ might invite a simple descriptive answer but instead gets this: You are never left alone during an operation. Your anaesthetist stays with you and keeps you safe, pain free and unaware of what is going on. Drugs are constantly being given to you throughout the operation to make sure you are kept safe and then once the operation is over the anaesthetist will wake you up…' This question, which could simply be one of curiosity, is used, as the leaflet's title might suggest, as an opportunity both for reassurance and also for education about the role of the anaesthetist in general. But while the answer mentions safety, the question does not. For the patient who had not considered that aspect of anaesthesia, might this be a disconcerting change of tone? Furthermore, it begs the question of what the patient is being kept safe from. The excesses of the surgeon? The undesired effects of the anaesthetic? Electrical, infectious or other hazards? Without qualification, ‘safe’ is not only meaningless but may actually provoke anxiety. An earlier question, ‘Will I be safe?’ did attempt to explore this in more detail, but the fact remains that our collective preoccupation with safety can inadvertently colour our interaction with patients. Although enabling choice is not the primary function of information materials, patient choice is now enshrined in the NHS Plan [13] and implicit in many official pronouncements about the organisation and delivery of care. This trend embodies consumerism in health care. This perspective informed the survey and research methods used in the 1980s to find out what patients thought, and also made the point that ‘patients’ are not always ill or patient-like. It can carry more negative connotations, for instance that ‘the customer is always right’. It is, however, fair to say that it implies freedom to choose and the right to complain but a variable degree of responsibility. Our attitudes to consumerism are likely to depend on context. For instance, many anaesthetists will embrace the idea of consumerism in our lives outside work but may be less willing to countenance consumerism as professional providers of healthcare services. This may be attributed in part to resistance to change but also to a justifiable doubt as to how far the notion of choice can be sustained. To illustrate this, we analysed how the issue of pre-operative fluid fasting was handled in a sample of patient information leaflets using the general principles of good patient information noted above [14]. Now this issue might be expected to be important to patients as it affects their comfort, but it is also an integral part of the preparation for surgery and should be given prominence, if only to let patients know what to expect. We recorded how many mentioned fasting, how many gave ‘up to date’ times, what evidence was given for times quoted, and the tone of the words used. Out of 51 general leaflets about anaesthesia collected by the College as part of their project, only 27 mentioned fasting. Fourteen of these gave ‘up to date’ fasting times and none quoted research evidence. The tone varied widely and although some text was intended to explain why fasting was necessary, it might appear unnecessarily threatening to patients. Take the sentence: ‘If you are sick when you are unconscious, your body cannot get rid of the vomit safely and you may choke, or drown because liquid has got into your lungs’. In pathophysiological terms this is quite true, though the severity described is uncommon. Our interpretation of this survey was that patient choice − in this case, deciding how long to abstain from fluids − was being limited in three ways. First, information was being withheld, either because the issue was simply omitted or because times were not given. Whilst this may not have been intended to conceal − it more probably reflects the inability of individual members of anaesthetic departments to agree on a policy − it effectively denies patients the opportunity to become more involved in this aspect of their care, and certainly prevents them questioning why local practice might vary from an evidence-based national standard. Second, people are put off making choices because of the way leaflets are written. This relates to expectations − both how we expect our patients to behave and how we influence their expectations of their own behaviour. Typically, the text of leaflets plays on peoples' fears, or simply commands them what to do. In view of the fact that patients generally do as they are asked in hospital, is this harshness strictly necessary? These two points can apply throughout many areas of healthcare, but the third − notions of safety − is perhaps more acute in anaesthesia than anywhere else. For we would refuse to do something a patient might choose if we felt that course of action was unsafe. This is a strongly held belief and probably explains why we tend to adopt draconian tones when our notions of safety are challenged. If patients choose to ignore our requests to abstain from food or drink, then we reserve the right, in their interest, not to anaesthetise them. Speaking as an anaesthetist, I think that this is entirely right and proper. What I think is improper is for patients to be led to believe that choice is as widespread as is sometimes implied. I think that this is unfair and misleading. As the leaflet Anaesthesia Explained (one of the series produced as part of the College project) was being drafted, it was decided to highlight possible ‘choice points’ in the text as opportunities for patients to exercise their right to choose, if they wished. Suggestions were invited. The anaesthetists responded with things such as ‘walking to theatre instead of going on a trolley’, but the patient representatives suggested a number of others: Which hand to insert the cannula into. Adults having local anaesthetic cream to numb the area for cannulation. Offering adults the opportunity for another adult to accompany them into the anaesthetic room. Offering the choice between regional and general anaesthesia when there is a ‘medical’ reason to favour one over the other. Encouraging patients to read the patient information leaflet for drugs to be used. Offering patients the opportunity to read the national or hospital protocols governing aspects of their anaesthetic care. Encouraging patients to ask why a particular form of care is not available (e.g. HDU). It might be supposed that anaesthetists find the items towards the end of the list more contentious, but the patient representatives on the project did not find any of them in the least controversial. It is clear that patients must be provided with more information rather than less, and that it is patients themselves that must be allowed to decide how much is too much. It is also clear that it is impossible to write patient information materials that satisfy everyone. Anaesthetists are often preoccupied with trying to convey something about their professional status and their impressive safety record. Patients need to know about the risks, partly to make informed judgements about different options but also to take a more active part in reducing them, if possible. The question then is, whose preferences should we favour? Is it possible to reconcile these two potentially conflicting views? My personal opinion is that we should acknowledge that anaesthesia is indeed potentially risky but that it is the skill, judgement and training of the anaesthetist that keep it acceptably safe for most patients. This gives us the opportunity to explain how complex and difficult our work is whilst at the same time treating patients as adults in that it does not attempt to pretend that everything is automatically absolutely safe when both we and they know it is not. It also explains why choice is limited − because of our culture of keeping things as safe as possible. To me, this is about equality of rights and responsibilities. We are happy to acknowledge that patients have the right to greater autonomy but ask them to acknowledge our professional right to avoid exposing them to what we consider unnecessary risks. We undertake to fulfil our responsibility of care towards them but ask in return that they act responsibly to help us keep them as safe as possible. To me the success of the Patient Information project will be measured not just in the number of downloads from the website, nor in the number of leaflets bought and distributed, but also in the subtle and enlightened shifts towards equality of both power and responsibility in the innumerable human encounters that take place between anaesthetists and patients every day. I would like to express my thanks to Dr Charlotte Williamson for her helpful comments on an earlier version of this paper.
Source: Anaesthesia
Author: Andrew F. Smith
Institution: Royal Lancaster Infirmary
Language: Spanish
Subfield: General Health Professions
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2403077382
