Work

Analytical study designs--I.

Year: 1994
Type: article
Abstract: What is a Case-Control Study?Case-control studies look for an association between a disease and exposure to a potential risk factor.The investigator first selects cases (persons with disease) and appropriate controls (persons without the disease).The researcher next obtains data on exposure to the risk factor(s) of concern in both groups.When Is it appropriate to select a Case-Control Study design?The case-control study is generally quick and Inexpensive to conduct.It is well suited for examining an association between a risk factor and a disease that is rare or has a long latent period.The researcher generally selects cases from persons already diagnosed to have the disease/outcome of concern.If the required number of cases for analysis are not already present, the researcher may have to recruit cases as they occur to obtain the necessary number of cases. How do I go about conducting a Case-Control Study?Conducting a case-control study is a 3 step process.The first step is to select cases.In doing so you have to pay particular attention to: i. Case definition: Cases i.e., diseases/outcome of interest should be defined using strict inclusion criteria to prevent an overlap between cases and controls and thus minimize results which are not easily explained.For the same reasons, it is also important to use exclusion criteria.For example, in identifring risk factors for cancer of the uterus, it would be appropriate to study cancer of the cervix and cancer of the corpus uteri separately, as risk factors for cervical cancer may differ from.thosefor cancer of the corpus uteri.ii.Selection of cases: Cases can be selected from records (hospital and other records) or identified through a community survey.Random selection of cases for study from a list of identified case makes the results from such a study more readily generalizable to the larger population.The second step is the selection of controls (those without the disease) which is necessary for comparison.i.Control definition: Controls should be comparable to case except with respect to the exposure under study.ii.Selection of Controls: Controls can similarly be chosen from the same hospital as the cases, or from the surrounding community.They should preferably be selected in a random manner, e.g., through the use of random tables, to avoid a systematic error.Hospital controls are those with conditions other than the disease being studied or diseases associated with the risk factor(s) under study.For example, if one wishes to study the relationship between tobacco use and lung cancers, inappropriate controls would be persons with chronic bronchitis.The proportion of smokers in both groups might be similar leading to the false conclusion that smoking is not related to lung cancer.The advantages of using hospital controls are that they are easily available.Controls chosen from the community are preferable to hospital controls.However, these persons are less likely (compared to cases) to recall information with respect to exposure-recall bias.Controls could thus be selected from relatives, friends or neighbours of cases as they would be more likely (because of interest in the case) to provide information on exposure to the risk factor(s) under study.Once the source of the control series has been determined, the next question to consider is the number of controls.Generally, the higher the ratio of controls to the case, the more likely the chance of detecting a difference in exposure to the risk factor.The ratio for cases-tocontrols can vary from 1:1 to 1:4.The third step is ascertainment of exposure status.Any source of information must be carefully considered in terms of its accuracy and comparability of information for all study groups.Sources could be (i) interviews with study subjects or surrogates, e.g., spouses of subjects or mothers of children, or (ii) data recorded in records (physician records, hospital records,
Source: PubMed
Institution: Aga Khan University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2406399261
FWCI:
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10