Work

Psychiatric Diagnostic Uncertainty: Challenges to Patient-Centered Care

Year: 2016
Type: article
Abstract: In this case and commentary, a patient's request to be treated for depression without a stigmatizing diagnostic label of bipolar II disorder challenges a clinician's obligation to provide a clinically and ethically appropriate diagnosis and safe treatment consistent with the patient's family medical history.Sensitively recognizing and responding to patients' concerns and values, even when they might conflict with the delivery of reasonable psychiatric care, is essential when gauging the appropriateness of such therapeutic practices.Furthermore, developing honest and open communication; recognizing that patients, like some psychiatric diagnoses, do not fit into discrete boundaries or cannot be categorized by a single label; and placing the patient at the center of care can all serve to resolve value conflicts, protect patient privacy, and promote accurate diagnostic and treatment practices. CaseTina, an 18-year-old college freshman, presents to a university mental health clinic complaining of symptoms of depression.She reports that she has been experiencing very low moods, crying spells, and a profound lack of energy and motivation, making it difficult to do even the most basic activities in her life.Moreover, the lack of motivation and problems with concentration have made it very difficult to keep up with her work, and Tina expresses the concern that she might fail out of school.She reports that one of her good friends from high school had something similar happen to her and responded well to sertraline, and that she was hoping that she could get a prescription for that.A careful history and lab tests reveal that Tina's symptoms are primarily isolated to the areas of mood, attention, motivation, and energy and that there is no medical or substance-induced cause of her symptoms.Tina reports no change in her appetite or sleep habits, no psychomotor agitation or retardation, no feelings of worthlessness or guilt, and no thoughts of suicide.When asked about the past, she says that for about a month after arriving at school she felt "fabulous."She was getting As in all her classes and excelling as a member of the cross-country team.Although she had been very worried about meeting new friends when she started college, she states, "Then I realized that I didn't have to worry about that at all, and that I was actually much more social
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2416153454
FWCI: 0.38
Cites: 5
Cited by: 13
Related to: 9