Year: 2016
Type: article
Abstract: E VEN IF MEN WERE ANGELS, the experience of Divine Revelationwould suggest the prudence of retaining the threat of punishment to keep them so.So long as non-angelic mortals seek pleasure and avoid pain, punishment will play a vital role in influencing human behavior, in intimidating actual offenders and in deterring would-be ones.But punishment, like the infliction of any pain, as an end in itself, is an evil.Those who insist that punishment is the just desert of crime, that punishment must fit the crime ("an eye for an eye"), or that punishment is the debt owed society by some criminal, may assert the unstudied belief of mankind.By viewing punishment as an end, they cannot justify its infliction.Only by considering it as a means, may punishment be properly evaluated.In this light, punishment is just or unjust in proportion as it serves or disserves the attainment of a good end.Punishment imposed to prevent crime promotes the common good, and is accordingly just.Punishment inflicted for the sake of vengeance, retribution, or sadistic satisfaction, promotes no common good, and is unjust.Those who would substitute lenient for punitive treatment of criminals, argue that the deterrent efficacy of threats of punishment is overrated.They insist that crime continues in spite of the threats because criminals seldom look ahead to the possible consequences of their lawless acts.How much greater the crime rate would be without such threats must remain conjectural: no society has yet been foolhardy enough to experiment with suspension of penalties for crime.As to the effect of such threats on criminals, this writer could only wish that his students, after a semester of exposure to criminal law materials, would acquire the ready grasp of subtle distinctions among various degrees of burglary tThe author has in substance reproduced a sentence or two from his writing, Peti- tion in the Matter of the Imprisonment of Archibishop Stepinac to the President of the United States (1946).
Source: The Catholic lawyer
Author: Frederick J. Ludwig
Institution: St. John's University
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2418277200
