Work

Questioning Evidence for Recombination in Human Mitochondrial DNA

Year: 2000
Type: article
Abstract: The possibility of recombination in human mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), raised recently by Awadalla et al. (1), holds crucial implications for many evolutionary studies (2). Here, we reexamine the data analyzed in (1), show that some of those data are likely unreliable, and suggest that the short-distance correlations found by Awadalla et al. (1) can be more plausibly interpreted phylogenetically. Awadalla et al. (1) examined 14 variable positions in 45 mtDNA genomes for distance correlation. The first of those positions, nucleotide 4985, is known to be a sequence error (3). In another position, nucleotide 6455, a T has been recorded in eight out of ten sequences from haplogroups M and U (4), while in other related haplogroup M genomes, it is a “conventional ” C (5). We analyzed 48 European and Asian haplogroup M and U mtDNA samples and did not detect any variation at this position; moreover, a C is present at this position in a sequence from sub-Saharan African haplogroup L1 sequence (6), as well as in the mitochondrial genomes of Pan paniscus and Pan troglodytes (7). Hence, a sequencing or typing error in (4) is a likely explanation. This does not exhaust the list of suspicious polymorphisms used in (1); sequence 12 from (8), for example, is likely a mosaic of haplogroup T – and H–type mtDNA genomes. Our next criticism is based on a phylogenetic argument. We have resequenced or typed by restriction enzymes seven sites used in the analysis of Awadalla et al. (1)—7028,
Source: Science
Authors: Toomas Kivisild, Richard Villems, L B Jorde, M Bamshad, S Kumar, P Hedrick, T Dowling, M Stoneking, T J Parsons, J A Irwin, P Awadalla, A Eyre-Walker, J M Smith
Language: English
Subfield: Genetics
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2423279358
FWCI: 9.069
Cites: 50
Cited by: 140
Related to: 9