Work

Experimental Analyses of Rule-Following:Methodological and Clinical Implications

Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The current thesis investigated the methodological and clinical implications of rulefollowing\nbehaviour. The research program comprised eight experimental studies,\nincluding the match-to-sample methodology and the use of radiant heat apparatus. Chapter\n1 provides a review of the available literature on rule-following, including empirical\nevidence of its clinical implications. Chapter 2 incorporated four studies that examined\nrule-following vs. contingency adaptation in a simple automated match-to-sample task\nbased on previous research (McAuliffe, 2004). In Experiment 1 (n=16), three Pliance\nconditions (with differing levels of Experimenter involvement) were compared to a\nTracking condition. In simple terms, the two types of condition were distinguished in terms\nof the Experimenter’s knowledge of the experimental rules with which participants had\nbeen provided. Although the results demonstrated a clear distinction between pliance and\ntracking, the experimental control of either was not as expected. Specifically, participants\nin Pliance showed evidence of tracking, with strong adaptation to changing experimental\ncontingencies. In contrast, participants in Tracking showed evidence of pliance, with\nperseverative rule-following even when the rules became inconsistent with the task\ncontingencies. In the former conditions, the activities of the Experimenter appeared to have\nlittle influence over responding.\nExperiment 2 (n=24) incorporated minor modifications to experimental instructions\nbased on participant feedback, as well as a greater sample size, to establish more reliable\nexperimental control over pliance and tracking. The results showed evidence of pliance in\nboth Tracking and Pliance conditions, thus raising further issues about experimental\n\ncontrol. To address these issues, Experiment 3 (n=16) replicated McAuliffe’s original\nprocedure without modification, paying particular attention to the original instructions and\nwith the removal of the instructions after participants had read them. The results recorded\nhere provided the clearest distinction between pliance and tracking (participants in\nTracking demonstrated tracking and Pliance demonstrated pliance), but were more like\noutcomes McAuliffe had reported with depressed, rather than non-depressed, participants.\nExperiment 4 (n=16) replicated Experiment 3, but participants retained the instructions\nafter they had read them. This variable appeared to have had some influence over the\nprevious outcomes when the data indicated a reduction in the distinction between pliance\nand tracking, with participants in Tracking showing increasing pliance and participants in\nPliance showing increasing tracking.\nChapter 3 incorporated two studies that compared pliance and tracking in the\ncontext of different rules (tolerance vs. subjectivity) for coping with experimentallyinduced\npain. Experiment 5 (n=40) attempted to replicate previous research by Hayes and\nWolf (1984), but replaced the cold pressor task with the radiant heat apparatus. Inconsistent\nwith previous evidence, four of the five conditions recorded decreases in heat tolerance,\nwith the exception of the Pliance/Subjectivity condition. Experiment 6 (n=40) replicated\nExperiment 5, but with the Experimenter absent during the heat tests. The results indicated\na notable distinction between pliance and tracking, in which pliance was associated with\ntolerance increases and tracking was associated with tolerance decreases.\nChapter 4 incorporated two studies that compared brief therapeutic acceptancebased\ninterventions vs. rules to determine which would exert greater influence on heat\ntolerance. Experiment 7 (n=32) systematically compared acceptance-based vs. placebo\nbased interventions and rules. Although the results were partly consistent with predictions\nwhen both Placebo conditions were associated with tolerance decreases, the outcomes for\nAcceptance were not as expected. Specifically, the Acceptance Intervention resulted in\nmarginal tolerance decreases, while the Acceptance Rule produced only marginal tolerance\nincreases. The final study, Experiment 8 (n=32), compared acceptance interventions and\nrules in pliance vs. tracking contexts to determine what impact this variable may have\nexerted on the previous findings. The results from Experiment 8 indicated that pliance was\nassociated with greater tolerance increases than tracking and the intervention overall\nproduced better tolerance than the rule. The current research raised a number of\nmethodological and conceptual issues that contribute to the existing literature on rulefollowing\nbehaviour and these are discussed in the final General Discussion Chapter 5.
Author: Marie Gorham
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2433807425
Cites: 62
Cited by: 3
Related to: 9