Work

The Good Monk and His Money in a Buddhist Monasticism of "The Mahayana Period."

Year: 2000
Type: article
Abstract: IT is probably fair to say that, because of the way they have been studied, neither Indian Buddhist monasticism nor the Buddhist monastery in India have been allowed to have anything like a real history.Whether implicitly or explicitly, conscious or not, most modem scholars have either unquestion ingly assumed, or worked hard to show, that extant monastic or vinaya sources, for example, must be early, some even asserting-or again assum ing-that they must go back to the Buddha himself.But the necessary con sequences of this have rarely been examined: if the extant vinaya sources are early, if they go back anywhere near the time of the Buddha, then Buddhist monasticism could not have any real institutional history-it could only have sprung all but fully formed from the head o f the Buddha.Moreover, since these extant vinaya sources already know and are meant to govern fully developed, well-organized, walled monasteries that had infirmaries, refectories, bathrooms, steam rooms, locks and keys, the Buddhist mona stery too could have had no real development, and consequently no actual history.It would have been architecturally finished from its very start.Such pictures-one is tempted to say fantasies-fit, of course, not at all well with what is known about monasticisms elsewhere.More importantly, and in specific regard to the Indian Buddhist monastery for which we have some independent, non-literary sources as well, it does not fit at all with what is found in the archaeological record of Buddhist monastic sites in India.The earliest Buddhist "monasteries 0 that are known in India-and none o f these are pre-A&okan-are not "monasteries 0 at all.They are either
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W245030149
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 24
Related to: 9