Increasing the accuracy of self-report data through the use of reliability enhancement and self-monitoring training procedures
Year: 1976
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The purpose of the present investigation was to: (a) assess the separate and combined effects of Self-monitoring Training (SMT) and Reliability Enhancement Package (REP) procedures on the self monitoring accuracy of speech anxious undergraduates, (b) compare SMT to a procedure designed to control for exposure to irrelevant training stimuli (i.e.. Training Control -TO) and REP to a manipu lation composed of accuracy instructions and a simple "record" cue (i.e.. Accuracy Instructions -AI), and (c) evaluate the effective ness of experimental procedures when the demand for behavior change was either "low" (unmanipulated) or "high" (manipulated).Twenty-eight speech anxious undergraduates, who had indicated an interest in participating in a speech anxiety treatment program, served as subjects.Seven subjects were included in each factorial combination (i.e., SMT-REP, SMT-AI, TC-REP, TC-AI) and all 28 par ticipated in the three self-monitoring speech sessions (i.e., SM I, II, and III).Participants were initially informed that treatment would consist of repeated exposure (i.e., flooding) to the actual feared situation (i.e., public speaking) and that they would be responsible for evaluating their progress by self-monitoring objective signs of anxiety (i.e., frequency of speech disfluencies) as well as subjective perceptions of fear during each speech performance.Sub jects self-monitored objective and subjective behaviors during the three separate speech sessions.The three speeches given during each session were unobtrusively recorded, thus allowing for a comparison to be made between the number of disfluencies self-monitored and the number actually emitted.Experimental procedures were administered between SM I and SM II and demand for behavior change was manipulated prior to the final speech session.Results indicated that: (a) SMT was more effective than TC in increasing the accuracy of self-monitored data, (b) REP as a sole accuracy-enhancing manipulation was more effective than AI only when the target behavior was easily discriminable, and (c) a combination of SMT and REP procedures proved most effective in improving the accuracy of self-monitored data and in maintaining these gains over time.
Author: Scott B. Hamilton
Institution: University of Montana
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2461290524
