Work

To Love or Not to Love: The Possibility, Promise, and Peril of Mutually Transformative Attorney-Client Friendships

Year: 2016
Type: article
Abstract: While the academy has largely focused on whether friendship is the best way to conceptualize the attorney-client relationship in the abstract, 10 this Article instead explores the benefits and drawbacks of attorney-client friendships through my relationship with Tyra Patterson.Drawing upon our experience, I argue that close personal friendships between lawyers and their clients could help achieve the clients' legal objectives while positively impacting the client in manners unrelated to the representation.My point is not that every lawyer should develop such close friendships with her clients, but rather that true attorney-client friendships may be mutually beneficial.Part I details the story of how our relationship began as a typical attorney-client relationship but transformed into something much deeper.11 Part II then explores whether what exists between us is a true friendship as understood by Western culture.Ultimately, I conclude that our relationship meets this standard.But is what I feel for Tyra also love, and if so, is that problematic?Part III attempts to answer these questions by discussing the four "loves" identified by Classical Philosophy: agape (love for God and mankind); eros (romantic and/or erotic love); philia (love of friendship); and storge (familial love).12 I conclude that agape, philia, and storge all describe my feelings towards Tyra.On reflection, I further realize that something like storge has existed in many of my 9 Robert J. Condlin, "What's Love Got to Do with It?"-"It'sNot Like They're Your Friends for Christ's Sake": The Complicated Relationship Between Lawyer and Client, 82 NEB.L. REV.211, 307-08 (2003).10See, e.g., supra notes 8-9 and accompanying text.11
Author: David A. Singleton
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2462404246
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10