Work

Analyzing avian nest survival in forests and grasslands : A comparison of the Mayfield and logistic-exposure methods

Year: 2007
Type: article
Abstract: Several new methods for analyzing avian nest survival have been developed recently.To date, few tests have compared the performance of these new approaches with the traditional approach to nest survival analysis, the Mayfield method.To address this question, we used the Mayfield method to reanalyze data on avian nest survival from two published studies that employed the logistic-exposure approach, one of the Mayfield alternatives.We found that both approaches yielded nearly identical point estimates of daily nest survival, although the Mayfield estimates were less precise than estimates generated by the logistic-exposure models.Hypothesis tests conducted via the two different approaches also yielded generally similar results, although in one of the studies the Mayfield analysis failed to identify one of the significant covariates revealed by the logistic-exposure approach, apparently due to the imprecision of the Mayfield estimates.In sum, our results suggest that estimates of nest survival generated using the Mayfield estimator or its alternatives will be comparable, and that results of studies conducted using the Mayfield method should not be discounted.At the same time, our results reinforce the previously demonstrated advantages of alternatives such as the logistic-exposure approach: the ability to evaluate complex models of nest survival, consider individual and continuous covariates, and produce more precise estimates of daily nest survival.
Authors: John D. Lloyd, Joshua J. Tewksbury
Language: English
Subfield: Ecology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2463474228
FWCI: 1.142
Cites: 213
Cited by: 15
Related to: 10