Work

On a sustainable development path? A comparative case study of Norway and Sweden’s national sustainable development strategies and indicators

Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis explores the phenomenon of national sustainable development strategies by\ncomparing such strategies for Norway and Sweden. Based on the operationalization of their\nstrategies into goals and indicators, it is possible to reflect upon whether Norway and Sweden are\non a sustainable development path. The background for the thesis is the threat of climate change\non the planet and its boundaries that may cause irreversible damages to future generations. The\nstarting point is the concept of sustainable development by the World Commission on\nEnvironment and Development (WCED) in 1987 (p. 8). The Rio-Initiative in 1992 addressed the\nclimate threat among other sustainable development issues in Agenda 21 by asking nations to\ndevelop national sustainable development strategies (UNCED, 1992). Such strategies and\nprocesses were studied by Dalal-Clayton (1996) in Getting to Grips with Green Plans. His\nframework of key lessons and guiding principles is the foundation for this thesis. The first\nNorwegian and Swedish plans are part of his study. His findings produced a basis, which are\nuseful for the exploration of the most recent strategies.\nThree research questions are defined, and the thesis is divided into corresponding parts. The\nresearch questions are seen in the light of two broad paradigms, weak sustainability and strong\nsustainability (Neumayer, 2013). The research strategy for the thesis is exploratory and abductive\nwith a qualitative approach using mostly secondary data on the two strategies and statistics on the\nindicators studied. The methods used are discourse and document analysis. The primary data\nfrom a few key informants provide background information and verify some of the findings. The\nfirst part finds that the Norwegian and Swedish strategies primarily have a weak understanding of\nsustainability. The second part explores the operationalization of strategies into goals and indicators for the two\nmain themes of the thesis, namely climate change and intergenerational justice. The framework\nof Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and the Stiglitz\ncommission form the basis for the discussion of indicator approaches chosen by Norway and\nSweden. Norway has chosen a capital approach with sub-themes to account for the economic,\nsocial and environmental dimensions of sustainable development. The main indicator for\nintergenerational justice in the Norwegian strategy is national wealth and non-declining welfare over time (St.prp. nr. 1 (2007-2008), 2007). On the other hand, the Swedish strategy has chosen\nan overall environmental goal for sustainable development where 16 environmental quality\nobjectives represent intergenerational justice (Comm. 2005/06:126, 2005). The statistical data on\nthe indicators show that Norway and Sweden will probably not meet their targets for climate\nmitigation by 2020. It may be questioned whether they are taking their burden of climate\nmitigation and are sustainable in the long run.\nThe third part of the thesis discusses the data for climate change and intergenerational justice\nusing two paradigms, weak and strong, as an analytical tool. It is demonstrated that it matters\nwhether one uses weak sustainability or strong sustainability to determine how Norway and\nSweden are contributing to global and national sustainability. The implications of applying weak\nsustainability may hinder Norway and Sweden in being on a sustainable development path\ntowards 2020 and 2050. If applying the strong sustainability paradigm, neither Norway nor\nSweden appears to be on a sustainable development path. Granted that there are uncertainties\nabout the future, the likelihood of becoming carbon natural by 2050 may also be jeopardized.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2463511767
Cites: 48
Cited by:
Related to: 10