Managed Networks of Competence in Distributed Organizations - The role of ICT and Identity Construction in Knowledge Sharing
Year: 2014
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Knowledge is seen as a main driving force for current public organizations to fulfill\ntheir mission in changing environments, and for some organizations the response is\nto design managed networks for knowledge sharing and learning. Distributed\norganizations, which this study examines, are particularly challenged to develop\nknowledge sharing and learning across distance to strengthen their operative units.\nCommunities of practice have become a central notion for the management of\nknowledge in organizations. However, the elaboration of communities of practice\nseems to assume that the members regularly work together or at least meet during\nlunchtimes and at meetings in which they share their work experiences. Some,\nthough, do not have the opportunity to work together or meet directly face-to-face,\nsince they are spread around large geographical areas. The purpose of the present\nwork is to elaborate on this issue.\nThis dissertation addresses gaps in existing literature regarding the role of managed\nnetworks and communities for knowledge sharing in distributed organizations. In\nparticular the role of collaborative ICT and identity construction is discussed. The\noverarching research question for this dissertation is: What are the main factors\nhampering and facilitating knowledge sharing through managed networks of\ncompetence? The two sub- questions are:\n1) What is the role of the GoToMeeting™ tool, when sharing knowledge in managed\nnetworks of competence?\n2) What is the role of identity construction for knowledge sharing in managed\nnetworks of competence?\nThe overarching theoretical idea that this dissertation extends is structuration\ntheory. ICTs are from this perspective seen as structural resources that shape the social practices of the participants using them while being influenced by this use.\nThrough this duality of technology comes the shape of the community and the\nidentities of those participating in it. This approach combines Giddens structuration\ntheory with Wengers theory on communities of practice, and emphasizes the social,\ntechnological and contextual factors that contribute to the dynamics of networks\nand communities of practice.\nThe empirical context includes the following networks: The Fishery Network in the\nNorwegian Taxation Authority and two accident networks, two networks for\npsychological well-being and the network for occupational hygiene in the Norwegian\nLabor Inspection Authority (main research site).\nThis research is aligned with the social constructivist approach to grounded theory\nwhere categories and concepts emerge from my interactions with the field and\nquestions about the data. The strength of this approach is twofold:\n1. The social constructionist view has the ability to uncover some of the\ncomplexity of human sense making. It views knowledge as socially\nconstructed through interactions in particular contexts. This perspective\ngoes beyond the deterministic perspectives of ICT and organizational\nstructure (network structure), where both are thought to have embedded\nfeatures influencing people.\n2. Grounded theory analysis is particularly useful for the explorative nature of\nthis research project. Data consist of interview data and observational data collected from 2008 to 2012.\nThis thesis contains five papers, contributing to different perspectives and the\nperspectives are:\nPaper 1: Media use, social networking and knowledge sharing,\nPaper 2: Work role identities and their barriers to online knowledge sharing,\nPaper 3: The sharing of work practice across distance,\nPaper 4: The use narration to overcome learning barriers when sharing complex\npractices, and, finally,\nPaper 5: Focusing on how the construction of identity influences the transfer of\nknowledge in a managed and online context.\nThis study offers deep insights into the role of the collaborative ICT tool\nGoToMeeting™ for knowledge sharing. Findings underline that the tool has\nlimitations regarding knowledge sharing, in particular for communities with a more\ninterpretative knowledge orientation. However, closeness to actual work practice is\nalso accomplished by the participants’ use of actual documents, stories and pictures\nwhen sharing online. Yet, the participants find it hard to interact socially, to get to\nknow each other and to discover who knows what, which is very important for\nknowledge sharing. Technology is not the only problem here. Other contextual\nfactors – individualism, group size, mixed signals from management, managerial\ncontrol and overload of top-down issues create problems for the networks.\nThe main theoretical contribution of this work is the enlargement of structuration\ntheory into knowledge sharing through online managed networks of competence.\nThe dissertation develops a perspective that views technology (ICT) as a medium for\nidentity construction. The findings underline that some work identities are more\ndifficult to signify online than other identities, hence influencing the trajectories of the communities in the organization. There is an emphasis in this dissertation that\nknowledge sharing is hard to enact in traditional ways online. Though, to some\nextent the participants establish new ways to share knowledge by means of\nstorytelling and the use of work documents and pictures from an inspected site.\nGrounded on this, the study contributes to the practice based idea that ICTs can\nfacilitate knowledge sharing by facilitating the observation of the work practices of\nothers. Furthermore, this study extended the emergent perspective on ICT use, and\nin particular the negative impact of ICT mediated multitasking from work activities\nto online networks of competence meetings.\nThis study contributes to the communities of practice literature, by changing the\nfocus from identity construction as a facilitator for knowledge sharing, as described\nin the literature on communities of practice, to the role of identity as a barrier which\nhamper knowledge sharing. The findings demonstrate that multiple and\ncontradictory identities create barriers linked to knowledge interests and\ncommitment. In particular, my study emphasizes the identity problems in the\nrelationship between old-timers and the newcomers which may hamper the sharing\nof experiences from old-timers to newcomers.\nThis dissertation contributes also to the study of organizational and social identity\nby extending the fragmented view of social identities and identity in organizations to\nmanaged networks of competence. Findings contributes to our understanding of the\ntensions between organizational knowledge and professional knowledge that is\nnurtured by the networks of competence, and the more tacit work-based\nknowledge which is usually constructed in a master–apprentice relationship during\nwork, which creates unclear learning trajectories for the newcomers participating in\nthe networks of competence. To nurture formal networks of competence, this study highlight that there is a need\nfor managers to; 1) better understand the participants traditional ways of sharing\nknowledge to support interaction, 2) take on an leadership role to clarify the\npurpose of the formal networks, but not control what network members are\ndiscussing, and finally 3) give the networks concrete tasks to develop their\ncompetencies, social network and in particular the know-who. Finally, I suggest that\nit is necessary to look more deeply into how ICT mediated knowledge sharing,\npersonnel turnover and organizational change in current organizations can change\ncommunities in organizations and how organizations add to the differences between\nthe generations as important areas which should be prioritized in future knowledge\nmanagement research.
Source: NVA (Nasjonalt vitenarkiv)
Author: Inge Hermanrud
Institutions: Nord University, University of Nordland
Language: English
Subfield: Information Systems and Management
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: knowledge sharing, distributed organizations, communities of practice, identity construction, structuration theory, knowledge management, public sector organizations, remote collaboration, industrial hygiene, psychological well-being, organizational learning, sensemaking, social construction of knowledge
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2467078571
