Year: 2015
Type: book
Abstract: Researchers at Cardiff University held a one day roundtable event on Transparency in the Court of Protection as part of a wider Nuffield Foundation funded project on welfare cases in the Court of Protection (CoP).The aim of the project is to gather high quality information to contribute to policy debates about transparency, efficiency and accessibility in the Court of Protection, and proposals for reform.This report describes the discussions at a roundtable on the theme of Transparency in the Court of Protection. 1 It was held in September 2014 at the Nuffield Foundation headquarters, and was attended by participants from a range of backgrounds, including members of the judiciary, lawyers with experience of acting for litigants in CoP welfare cases, media lawyers, journalists and other professionals working in media, civil servants and researchers.Proceedings in the Court of Protection involve a delicate balance between transparency and open justice, on the one hand, and the preservation of the right to respect for privacy for the intimate details of the life of the person who is alleged to lack capacity.All participants expressed support for the principle of 'open justice'.Media reporting on CoP cases, and the publication of judgments, were said to be important for the following reasons:-To enhance public understanding of the CoP's work; -To protect against miscarriages of justice; -To promote public confidence in the court; -'Open' and 'accessible' judgments were said to be important for access to justice for litigants in person who might not have access to law reports or legal advice.45 Mr Justice Munby (2005) 'Access to and Reporting of Family Proceedings', paper presented at Jordan's Family Law Conference, London, on 1 December 2005.46 Lord Chancellor's Department (1993) Review of Access to and Reporting of Family Proceedings, London; Select Committee on Constitutional Affairs (2005) Family Justice: The operation of family courts.Volume 1, (HC 116-I) House of Commons, London; Department for Constitutional Affairs (2005) Disclosure of Information in Family Proceedings Cases Involving Children: Response to the public consultation, (Cm 6623) London; Department for Constitutional Affairs (2007) Confidence and confidentiality: Improving transparency and privacy in family courts.Response to Consultation, (CP(R) 11/06; Cm 7036) Department for Constitutional Affairs and Her Majesty's Courts Service; Ministry of Justice (2007) Confidence and Confidentiality: Openness in family courts -a new approach, (Cm 7131) London; Ministry of Justice (2008) Family Justice in View: Response to consultation, (CP(R) 10/07) London.47 Ministry of Justice (2011) The Family Courts Information Pilot: November 2009-December 2010 London.48 Ministry of Justice (2007) Confidence and Confidentiality: Openness in family courts -a new approach, (Cm 7131) London; Brophy, J. (2010) The views of children and young people regarding media access to family courts, The Children's Commissioner for England, London; Brophy, J., Perry, K., Prescott, A. and Renouf, C. (2014) Safeguarding, Privacy and Respect for Children and Young People: The Next Steps in Media Access to Family Courts, National Youth Advocacy Service and Association of Lawyers for Children.49 Sir James Munby (2013) 'Address by the President', paper presented at Annual Dinner of the Family Law Bar Association, Middle Temple Hall, London, on 22 February 2013.50 Sir James Munby (2013) 'Opening up the Family Courts: Transparency in the Family Court and the Court of Protection', paper presented at Annual Conference of the Society of Editors 'Freedom to Inform' London, on 11 November 2013.51 Judiciary of England and Wales (2014) Transparency in the Court of Protection.Publication of judgments, Practice Guidance issued on 16 January 2014 by Sir James Munby, President of the Court of Protection, London.70 The Select Committee on the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (2013) Evidence Session No. 14. Tuesday 26 November 2013.Witnesses: Mr Justice Charles, Senior Judge Denzil Lush, District Judge Margaret Glentworth and District Judge Elizabeth Batten
Language: English
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: Nuffield Foundation
OpenAlex ID: W606739224
