Work

Techno-economic examination of midsexualism

Year: 1984
Type: dissertation
Abstract: A midsexual has been definied as any individual who may or may not retain his socialized gender id e n tity , but who displays physiological or behavioral characteristics of the opposite sex that allow him to assume the corresponding gender role in most situations, early and continuing throughout the l i f e cycle.The purpose of this study was to examine midsexualism from a cultural m a te ria lis t perspective and determine under what conditions midsexuals are more lik e ly to ex is t and be accommodated.Through the use of the Human Relations Area f ile s and other supporting information, midsexuals were id en tified in 140 societies in the world, 30 of which were chosen fo r a detailed analysis using both s ta tis tic a l and ethnographic data.I t was found that midsexuals were more lik e ly to exist and be accommodated in societies where female economic participation and control were high or at least s ig n ific a n t.In contrast, midsexualism was rarer in cultures with predominant male contributions and the accommodation shown midsexuals also tended to be less.These general conclusions were further supported by additional evidence indicating greater accommodation fo r male midsexuals than female ones in midsexual present societies.The difference in accommodation was related to the dual economic role adopted by male midsexuals and its lack of reproductive c o n flic t.F in a lly , an attempt was made to look at current attitudes towards midsexuals in the United States and relate them to current techno-economic conditions.question: under what circumstances are these people more lik e ly to exist and what does this say about the nature of sex roles in general?The intent of this thesis w ill be to address that question and come to some conclusions based on the ethnographic evidence.F irs t, however, certain definitions must be c la r ifie d .Sex Role: In using the term, I have relied on Money and Erhardt's (1972) d e fin itio n that i t consists of two complementary aspects-gender id en tity and gender ro le .Gender id en tity refers to an individual's sense of himself as male or female, while gender role emphasizes the behavior and characteristics that allow him to be correctly id en tifie d by other members of his society.While Money and Tucker (1975:9) use the term "gender id e n tity /ro le " to indicate the unity of the concepts, I found the terminology too cumbersome and w ill use either gender or sex role when talking about these aspects together.Transsexual: Although many d iffe re n t definitions of the word e x is t, I have chosen to subscribe to the one offered by Money and Tucker, (1975:31) that a transsexual's "gender id en tity has swung a ll the way over against his anatomy."The transsexual feels antagonistic towards his physical sex and its accompanying gender role and, to the degree allowed by his society w ill try to assume the gender role and appearance that corresponds to his gender id en tity up to and including surgical transformation.Transvestite: Again, the definitions vary.I prefer the narrow defin itio n offered by Kessler and McKenna (1979:14) that a transvestite is "someone whose gender id en tity corresponds to his/her sex assignment, but who obtains erotic pleasure by dressing as the other gender."Berdache; This term has been used interchangeably with transvestite in the lite r a tu r e .However, since berdaches can also be hermaphrodites can frequently adopt behaviors of the other sex in addi tion to sexual practices, I f e lt the two terms should be kept separate.Usually, berdache is used to refer to "a person, usually male, who was anatomically normal but assumed the dress, occupations and behavior of the other sex to e ffect a change in gender status" (Callender and Kochems 1983:443).Hermaphrodite or Intersexed: Definitions s t i l l vary.However, the view that a hermaphrodite is "an individual having both male and female reproductive organs" appears to be the most inclusive (Angelino and Shedd 1956:124).Midsexual: An individual who may or may not retain his socialized gender id e n tity , but who displays physiological or behavioral characteristics of the opposite sex that allow him to assume the corresponding gender role in most situations, early'and continuing throughout the l i f e cycle.I have coined this term to simplify referring to transsexuals, berdache, hermaphrodites and others which f i t within the category and also to exclude individuals such as transvestites as they have been defined here, who do not meet the c r i te r ia .These definitions represent a starting point.The remainder of the thesis w ill be devoted to answering the question already raised: under what circumstances are midsexuals more lik e ly to exist and be accommodated and what implications does this have for the study of sex roles in general?In undertaking th is analysis, I have begun by outlining my theoretical position.Next, I w ill evaluate several expl nations fo r the existence of midsexuals and discuss selected factors which might influence the degree of midsexual accommodation.F in a lly , w ill compare differences in frequency and d istrib utio n of male and female midsexuals and examine current trends in the United States towards midsexuals.A summary w ill review this information and state the conclusions reached on the basis of the ethnographic evidence and supporting s ta tis tic a l information.Chapter Two Theoretical Orientation Most of the anthropological information on midsexuals comes from two sources.The f i r s t is early accounts given by traders, trappers and other explorers in the 19th and 18th centuries.The second comes from ethnographic reports and descriptions written by anthropologists from 1900 to 1950.During the la tte r period anthropology was also dominated by the histo rical reconstructionist school founded by Franz Boas.Consequently, many of the interpretations that have been made about midsexuals are based on a Boasian theoretical orientation.In this the sis, however, the intent is to examine midsexualism from the perspective of cultural materialism.The follow chapter w ill concentrate on com paring m a te ria lis t and id e a lis t approaches and discussing th e ir u t i l i t y for anthropological research, especially in the area of social organi zation.The term cultural materialism was f ir s t coined in 1968 by Marvin Harris to describe an anthropological research strategy based on the principle of techno-environmental and techo-economic determinism.According to th is view, sim ilar technologies applied to sim ilar environ ments tend to result in sim ilar patterns of production and distribution and that these foster sim ilar kinds of social groupings which are ju s tifie d and maintained through sim ilar systems of values and b eliefs."Translated into a research strategy, the principle of techno-environ mental, techno-economic determinism assigns p rio rity to the study of the material conditions of socio-cultural l i f e , much as the principle of cultural materialism does not see ideology as the major in it ia t o r of change.Rather, i t is the return of women to the work force and th e ir resumption of a degree of economic control that allow such ideas as women's lib eratio n to take root.Harris applies this model to the changes in modern sex roles since the industrial revolution.As he observes: When there was an agrarian homesteading, fro n tie r in frastruc tu re , fam ilies were large and women's roles as mother and unpaid domestic laborer were emphasised.With urbanization and the increasing cost of reproduction re la tiv e to the benefits expected from children, women began to "raise th e ir consciousness" demanding entrance into the general employment market on an equal basis with males.Clearly the conscious-raising process has been an important instrument for lib eratin g women from the role of domestic drudge.But one cannot argue that p o litic a lideological struggle by women was responsible for the vast shifts in technology, production, demand for cheap labor, rise of c it ie s , and the increased costs of rearing children, and so fo rth -a ll of which provide the functional infrastructural con ditions upon which the propogation and am plification of modern feminist p o litica l-id e o lo g ic a l struggle is premised (1979:73).Applying these principles, cultural m aterialists have sought to explain such diverse topics as in fan tic id e , the agricultural revolution w itch cra ft, warfare and food taboos (Harris 1974) (Ross 1978).Field ethnographies have also been conducted, a good example being Roy Rappaport's 1967 work Pigs for the Ancestors.This book focuses on the Maring, a ho rticu ltural group in New Guinea and examines the origin and u t i l i t y of th e ir pip centered religious beliefs from a techno-economic perspective.According to trib a l lo re , pigs must be periodically sacri ficed to dead ancestors in a ceremony called the Kaiko.Held approxima te ly every twelve years, the ritu a l involves the slaughter of most of the group's pigs in a huge feast that cumulates with the men going to wage war with neighboring groups.The fighting continues until theTABLE 1 MIDSEXUAL PRESENT SOCIETIES IDENTIFIED IN
Author: Mary Courtis
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2468805943
Cites: 45
Cited by:
Related to: 10