Ruling vs. Dialogical Relations: NGOs, Women, and Institutional Power in Anti-Trafficking Campaigns in Russia
Year: 2010
Type: article
Abstract: In this paper, I discuss the nature of relations between anti-trafficking professionals and trafficking victims who receive assistance through reintegration programs administered by the International Organization for Migration and local NGOs in Russia and Ukraine.First, I analyze "ruling relations" (Smith 1999, 2005) within the anti-trafficking organizations, paying special attention to the processes of bureaucratization and institutionalization within them.Second, I identify certain spaces within the hierarchal structure of NGOs as institutions, where dialogical relations can take place and clients can participate in the NGOs' activities.Lastly, I analyze how trafficking victims craft individual identities using dialogue containing institutional definitions.The paper is based on data collected during field research in Russia and Ukraine in 2004-2006.During this field research, I conducted multiple interviews with female victims of sex trafficking who received social assistance in non-governmental organizations in different regions of Russia and Ukraine.
Author: Nadia Shapkina
Institution: Kansas State University
Language: English
Topic: Sex work and related issues
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: anti-trafficking campaigns, sex trafficking, trafficking victims, ruling relations, dialogical relationship, non-governmental organizations, International Organization for Migration, reintegration programs, bureaucratization, institutionalization, institutional power, women, client participation, identity construction, Russia, Ukraine
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W1523240524
