Work

Transcending disadvantage: life-histories of learners at a township school in South Africa

Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This is a study of the discourses of empowerment and disempowerment that emerge from the critical discourse analysis (CDA) of life-histories written by two classes of Grade 11 high school learners in a township school in Cape Town, South Africa.The line of argument presented by this thesis is that there are political, socio-economic, familial and institutional factors and the discourses that construct them which affect learners' resilience.These however do not determine this to the exclusion of individual agency.This thesis will demonstrate that these factors, discourses and individual learners' responses to them can be identified through an analysis of learners' life-histories.Township teachers particularly need to learn to elicit and interpret these life-histories so that they can identify the signs and roots of resilience and of its opposite.This will allow them to respond appropriately in ways that maximize and foster resilience in learners.The study is situated within Late Modernity and Post-structuralism, as well as in postcolonialism.It draws its extensive literature review from the work of, among others, Giddens (1991), Bandura (2002), Noguera (2003), Pennebaker (2003), Pienaar and Bekker, (2007), Ryan (1971), Roemer (1995), Whitty (2002), Willig (1992), and Wodak (1996).Data generation tools used in this qualitative ethnography include participant observation, semistructured interviews, home-visits and life-histories.The qualitative lens of the analysis, probed both the content of what was being said, how the message was being put across as well as the perceived impact of the message on the reader.The quantitative analysis of the data, on the other hand, was done in line with Pennebaker's 'word count' strategy (2003).In line with this I took stock of the rate at which particular words were used in the essays, e.g. the stem of the verb 'own' and its variants which appeared to dominate particularly the Grade 11A data.Drawing on the work of Roemer (1995) the qualitative findings are grouped according to the following categories:• The past of others;• Their own past actions; and • The needs of others.To these, I added a fourth category which merits a chapter in its own right, viz.'envisioning the future'.The findings suggested by this study, despite their not being generalizeable across contexts, present researchers, working within the South African context, with a special and unique set of circumstances, which warrants intensive study.If it is not a theory of empowerment or enablement that we can get out of this study, then the hypotheses generated here should generate new beginnings toward the development of such a theory, or at least new branches of existing theory (e.g. the theory of resilience).Beyond the individual discourses, the study concludes that various factors as suggested in the first paragraph above, form the backdrop to an individual's discourses of disempowerment or empowerment.Disempowerment and under-achievement being somewhat interlinked, the study i
Author: Susan Ntete
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2472025120
Cites: 127
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10