Resource partitioning and browse use by sympatric elk mule deer and white-tailed deer on a winter range in western Montana
Year: 1995
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Resource Partitioning and Browse Use by Sympatric Elk, Mule Deer and White-Tailed Deer on a Winter Range in Western Montana (228 pp.) Director: C. Les Marcumx^f^^^^^^^/ Wintering ecology and forage relationships of sympatric elk (Cervus elaphus) .mule deer (Odocoileus hemiorius) and white-tailed deer ( 0. vireinianus) , were studied on the Blackfoot-Clearwater Wildlife Management Area from 1991-1994.Twenty vegetation types were delineated along 40 km of transects.Winter aerial counts indicated that cervid densities were about 28/km^.Winter mortality, habitat use and distribution of elk, mule deer (MD) and white-tailed deer (WTD) were evaluated by counting carcasses and 61,671 track-sets along 320 km of total transect distance during 1992 and 1993.Cervid spatial distributions were also estimated using radio telemetry.Winter carcass densities were <l/km^, and recruitment was slightly greater than regional estimates for elk, MD and WTD.Variability was observed in fecal analysis estimates of cervid diets during both winters.Winter diets of elk were dominated by graminoids, whereas MD and WTD used conifers most.MD and WTD increased use of forbs and low-evergreen shrubs during a mild winter.Tree lichens (Alectoria spp.) were used by elk, MD and WTD.Burned grasslands influenced elk diets more in 1992 than did a harsher winter in 1993.Diets of MD and WTD were most influenced by harsh winter conditions.Variation in habitat selection by cervids was probably in response to forage availability, energetic costs of movement related to snow conditions, and thermal differences between habitats.Elk used large are as comprised of _jnany habitats, and jmade_ ^greatest use of ^eas wl'th ^sparse overstory canopy-eover.^WTD had the smallest herd home range and ^rèTièd on~Tïabitats with abundant overstory canopy.MD_used"h.abitatsintermediate to those used by elk and WTD.Elk movement appeared least restricted by deep snow.MD used sites with deep-crusted snow (>41 cm) during both winters, but WTD avoided such sites.Resource-use overlap among elk, MD and WTD was relatively low both winters.Overlap was greater between elk and both deer species in 1992, which was influenced by a recent wildfire.Overlap between MD and WTD was low both years because of high spatial separation.High spatial overlap between elk and MD was offset by low dietary similarity.Overall, periods with deep snow did not increase overlap.These results provided evidence that interspecific competition may have functioned in shaping niche relationships.Browse production and utilization varied across types.S i ^s on sou&h^aspects produced more browae-and-received-greater^ use than sites on north aspects.Serviceberry (Amalanchier alnifolia) was the dominant producer.Browse as sole forage for cervids at observed densities would supply food for about 9 d a y s .Periodic cervid population reductions in conjunction with prescribed burning would improve productivity of winter forage.More dense-mature conifer stands are needed to provide severe winter cover for WTD. Winter severity indices, browse sampling m e t h o d s , and vegetation descriptions are also presented. iiI was provided with an immense amount of financial, physical and emotional support during the 4.5 years of this project.
Author: Gary Ross Baty
Institution: University of Montana
Language: English
Subfield: Ecology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDG: Life on land
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2472155085
