Year: 1975
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This study investigates the effects of expectations on sp< clinicians' behaviors in the evaluation of nasality in tape recort voice samples.Nineteen female graduate students in Speech Pathology and Audiology were chosen as subject (raters) according to criteria that provided trained sources of expectations.They rated their per ceived nasality in two sequences of 40 backward-played, audio-taped voice samples of normal third and fourth grade boys.In the first sequence, 20 of the samples were randomly assigned the label "cleft palate" with the remaining 20 labeled "normal."A second sequence con sisted of the same 40 samples in a re-randomized order with the sample labels reversed from those of the first sequence. A 2X2X19 analysis of variance and a Scheffe test indicated that speech clinicians can be biased by the expectation effect in their evaluation of voice samples.The analyses indicated that within each of the two sequences and in some comparisons across both sequences the clinicians, as a group, rated samples labeled "cleft palate" more nasal than samples labeled, "normal."The analysis of variance and the Scheffe test produced no supporting data for the second experimental hypothesis:rating differences according to label would decrease from the first to the second sequence.Instead, the analyses showed that the label differences were greater in the second sequence than the first.A trend analysis indicated a linear increase in the scale values regard less of sample label throughout the experiment.This linear trend may have been the result of operation of an extraneous variable(s): loss of reality based referents and consequently resulted in enhancement of the label effect and implied directions to find nasality.Differences in the performance of raters were analyzed for significance in the analysis of variance in order to isolate this source of variability from the analysis of the effects of labels and sequences.These results revealed a significant difference in the performance of individual raters.Additional analyses showed that most raters were affected by labels, some more than others, and a few raters were influenced very little or not at all by the expectation effect.Many people associated with the University of Montana, Moorhead State University, Missoula Public Schools and Great Falls Public Schools were responsible for the origin and completion of this thesis.To appropriately acknowledge all individuals involved would require additional volumes, however, several key people must be mentioned.Thesis committee members Miss Cynthia Harrell, Dr. Kelly L yndes, and Dr. Duane Pederson
Author: Kenneth Hammer Rue
Institution: University of Montana
Language: English
Subfield: Oral Surgery
Field: Dentistry
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: University of Montana
OpenAlex ID: W2473784419
