Year: 1991
Type: article
Abstract: Work by Rising and Somers (1989) and Freeman and Jackson (1990) has recently emphasized that multiple, and preferably skeletal, measurements provide a more accurate assessment of body size in birds than do single, external measurements.We agree.It is regrettable, however, that both papers perpetrate a confusion between two useful and quite distinct variables: body size and body mass.In doing so they have ignored several highly relevant published studies, notably of nonpasserine and European spedes (the latter bias apparently part of a more general trend identified by Enckell 1988).Rising and Somers (1989) and Freeman and Jackson (1990) are but two recent examples of a widespread misunderstanding.Smith et al. (1990) provide a further instance.Another is the inclusion by Davies et al. (1988) of mass in an analysis of body size of Lesser Snow Geese (Chen c. caerulescens), which was criticized recently by Alisauskas and Ankney (1990), although in this case the overall interpretation of a size-related variation in fecundity of Lesser Snow Geese may not have been affected (Cooke et al. 1990).Even Peters (1984), in his extensive discussion of the ecological implications of body size, provides no clear definition of body size and in many instances discusses body size-related phenomena through body mass.Although not stated explicitly, both Rising and Somers (1989) and Freeman and Jackson (1990) addressed problems of measuring structural size.The Oxford dictionary defines structural as "of the (essential) framework" and structural size accordingly as "the size of the essential framework" (Piersma 1984).Because individual birds have a remarkable capacity to vary their mass and volume depending on their nutritional status, we feel it is biologically most meaningful to define structural size as the "nutrient reserve-independent size of a bird."Our point is simple.There is an important but widely ignored distinction that must be made between two concepts: (1) the reserve-independent structural size and (2) the variable amounts of nutrients (chiefly fat and protein) that permit birds to exercise and to survive periods of negative energy and nutrient balance, the variable nutrient reserve mass.Body mass
Authors: Theunis Piersma, Nick C. Davidson
Language: English
Topic: Avian ecology and behavior
Subfield: Ecology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2483330987
