Work

Interrater reliability of tests evaluating anatomical risk factors for ACL injury in elite female football and handball players

Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Background: A cohort was set up at the Oslo Sports Trauma Research Centre in 2007\naiming at investigating risk factors for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries in elite\nfemale football and handball players. The reliability and measurement error of the tests\nincluded in the cohort has not been established for this sample.\nObjective: To test the interrater reliability of a series of tests evaluating anatomical risk\nfactors for ACL injury in elite female football and handball players. The anatomical risk\nfactors are generalized joint laxity (GJL), genu recurvatum, knee laxity, hip anteversion\nand 12 anthropometric measures.\nMethods: A protocol was designed for establishing interrater reliability of the following\nanatomical measures: generalized joint laxity (GJL), genu recurvatum, knee laxity, hip\nanteversion and 11 anthropometric measures of the lower limbs and height. The players\nwere tested and retested on two separate days with intervals varying between 2−51 days.\nReliability was assessed using a set of statistical tests; intraclass correlation coefficients\n(ICC2.1), root mean square error (RMSE), paired t-test, Wilcoxon signed rank test and\nBland-Altman plots.\nResults: 42 female athletes (22 football and 20 handball players) were included. Mean\n± SD age, football players: 21.1 ± 3.2 and handball players: 21.9 ± 4.4. The interrater\nreliability was moderate for measures of knee laxity on the right side, ASIS width, and\nbilateral tibial and femoral widths (ICC2.1 0.55−0.65). Low interrater reliability was\nfound for knee laxity on the left side, bilateral genu recurvatum, hip anteversion on the\nleft side, bilateral tibial and femoral widths and femoral-tibial ratio on the right side\n(ICC2.1 0.29−0.44). Femoral-tibial ratio on the left side and hip anteversion on the right\nside showed little if any correlation (ICC2.1 0.17−0.22). Measuring height had the\nhighest correlation (ICC2.1 0.99). The GJL showed no difference between the two days\nof testing.\nConclusion: The interrater reliability of the anatomical tests included in this study\nvaried from little to very high reliability. A greater variance of the sample, continuous\nvariables, double-blinding, intrarater testing prior to the study, better piloting and better\ntraining of the testers are alterations that might have improved the results of this study.
Language: English
Subfield: Surgery
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2505907443
Cites: 108
Cited by:
Related to: 10