Year: 2015
Type: article
Abstract: A s the first and most prominent Christian writer, why did Paul have so little to say about Jesus of Nazareth and his earthly ministry?Why didn't Paul quote more of Jesus's teaching?These questions have been variously posed for a long time.In some academic circles the tendency has been to take Paul's minimal use of Jesus material as evidence that the apostle was not interested in the earthly Jesus, but only the risen Christ.While the vast majority of critical scholars make no such claim, a few contend that from his later theological viewpoint, Paul "retrofitted" Jesus with divine attributes and his death with salvific significance.This argument-assuming that Paul's sparing use of Jesus's teachings implies his lack of interest in the earthly Jesus-allegedly points to the conclusion that Paul is the true founder of Christianity. 1 The controversy continues to elicit strong responses from traditional quarters.2 While many scholars are minimalists in their approach, finding in Paul's letters only a handful of references to the teaching of Jesus, others go to the opposite extreme, some listing upwards of 100 quotes and allusions.The reality is probably somewhere inbetween.3 The range of opinions reminds us of the ambiguity of the evidence.In turn, this ambiguity causes one to wish for more satisfactory answers.A standard answer to the question of Paul's supposed lack of interest in Jesus's ministry has been that Paul's writings are epistles, a literary genre that was not given to conveying historical information.Moreover, Paul wrote theology, supposedly by its nature an abstraction not primarily focused on historical facts.Yet from Paul's letters themselves we know that neither of these things was necessarily true: Paul's theology is centered on the crucifixion of Jesus of Nazareth-that is, on historical persons and events.In addition, the epistle as a writing form was quite flexible: Paul and the other New Testament writers were free in adapting and shaping their chosen literary vehicles, adding historical information when they chose (for example, see Gal 1.13-2.10;Phil 3.4-6; 2 Cor 11.22-33; 1 Tim 6.13; etc.).Another answer, recently given from the perspective of sociology, suggests that it was the social setting of Palestinian churches versus the Hellenistic churches and their differing "survival strategies" which set the stage for different handling of Jesus's earthly ministry.Such strategies in Palestine involved demonstrating the church's uniqueness over against its parent Jewish faith, emphasizing Jesus's ministry and teaching, whereas survival in the Hellenistic world (allegedly) involved assimilation to the surrounding culture, demonstrating that Christians were not a threat nor were they antisocial.Thus, instead of focusing on the earthly ministry of A Thief in the Night: Paul and Jesus
Source: Leaven
Author: Thomas Scott Caulley
Institution: Kentucky Christian University
Language: English
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2509983190
