Q Methodology as a needs assessment tool for biology graduate teaching assistants participating in an instructional training program
Year: 2013
Type: article
Abstract: The purpose of this study is to demonstrate how Q Methodology can be used as a needs assessment tool for a Biology graduate teaching assistant (GTA) instructional training program.GTAs are used as the instructors of an increasingly diverse population of undergraduate students.GTAs are a diverse population of students with varying amounts of pedagogical preparation, research abilities, and motivation to complete their graduate study.They are often expected to prepare and grade exams, write their own syllabi, design course curriculum, prepare and present lectures, monitor student progress, hold office hours, and assign final grades, all with minimal faculty supervision.Although not all GTAs will become professors, many will, and the teaching assistantship remains the major preparation for their roles as faculty members.Since the majority of science professors have been GTAs, this instructional training program is of critical importance.Approaches to developing instructional training programs for GTAs vary from departmental workshops to campus-wide instructional seminars.Program evaluation is an intrinsic part of assuring that such programs best serve GTA needs, and that GTAs can best fulfill their roles in their respective departments.Q Methodology offers a number of potential advantages over traditional survey techniques for assessing needs of GTAs throughout their graduate school career, allowing program supervisors to evaluate and modify the program relative to GTA needs.Q Methodology allows the researcher to identify and interpret various viewpoints the GTAs hold in regard to graduate school.iii This is not only important to the supervisors of GTA instructional programs, but to the GTAs.This Q Methodology study led to three GTA viewpoints ("The Emerging Teacher," "The GTA Who Prefers Research," and "The Anxious GTA") that provide insight about GTA and programmatic needs.Q Methodology can provide predictor profiles, or "typologies" that are more useful than simple variables and demographic information for the classification of people, especially within program evaluation (Newman & Ramlo, 2011)."The Anxious GTA" viewpoint, which suggests a group of GTAs who may be at risk for failure in their degree program, may be further investigated for retention and program completion.The results of this study will be used to consider potential changes or updates to the existing training program that may include scaffolding, differentiation, peer or faculty mentoring, or self-directed learning strategies.It was Dr. Jennifer Milam who accepted me as her grad student when I felt there was no way to move forward.She truly taught me what it was like to look at situations from another's perspective, and in doing so, made me realize my position was never fixed -it was always evolving.I'd also like to show my appreciation to Dr. Susan Ramlo for giving me that "Eureka!!!" moment, where I came to love a methodology almost as much as I love Biology.Through her, and our beloved Q, I've been accepted into a community and made friends around the world.I now see every situation as a great new Q-Study, and for that, I am grateful.I'd like to express my sincere thanks to Dr. Joel Duff, Dr. Gary Holliday, and Dr. John Nicholas, my committee, for challenging me to continually adapt my ideas.I have to thank my family for allowing me to take the time to pursue my Ph.D. My mother, Lois, and my father, Bruce picked up my son, Matthew (AKA Guppy), many nights while I attended classes.They all put up with my moods when I'd stay up late writing, and my anxiety about my dissertation.This was truly a group effort, and I'm lucky to be loved so much, and that my support network saw the silver lining
Author: Amy B. Hollingsworth
Institution: University of Akron
Language: English
Topic: Q Methodology Applications
Subfield: General Social Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
Funders: Academy of Finland, Eurostars
OpenAlex ID: W2521243402
