Work

Tosaka Jun’s Critique of Hermeneutics

Year: 2016
Type: article
Abstract: In Philosophers of Nothingness, An Essay on the Kyoto School (2000), James \nHeisig laments that recognition of the Kyoto School of Philosophy and its \nachievements has generally been retarded both in and outside Japan. The \nreason for this retardation is that the formative years of the Kyoto School \n(the decades leading up to the Second World War) coincided with a period \nof intense Japanese nationalism. As a result, the Japanese themselves did not \nconsider the Kyoto School worthy of devoting much attention to after the \nSecond World War; any mention of the Kyoto School had disappeared by \nthe 1970s. Western philosophers eventually took an interest in the Kyoto \nSchool, initially by simply ignoring its troubling political record (Heisig, \n2000, pp. 3-6). The Kyoto School of Philosophy formed itself around its \nmain representative Nishida Kitarō1 in the years after the publication of \nhis maiden work Zen no Kenkyū (translated as An Inquiry into the Good) in \n1911. If one ignores his political writings, then from Nishida’s oeuvre can \nbe distilled a religious philosophy of mind which draws on ideas formulated \nin Zen Buddhism to theorize a form of consciousness that transcends \nthe dichotomy of subject and object (what Nishida’s friend D.T. Suzuki \nwould identify as satori, or enlightenment). It comes as no surprise that \nHeisig, a leading scholar on the Kyoto School, chooses to depoliticize \nNishida as much as possible. That behind Nishida’s seemingly innocent \nreligious philosophy of mind possibly lurk fascist motivations is something \nany conceptually-oriented philosopher would rather leave to colleagues \nfrom the Area Studies to further unravel. To comparative philosophers \nsuch as Heisig, Nishida’s achievements in the field of metaphysics, and \ncertainly not his political mishaps, deserve most of our scholarly attention. \nHowever, philosophers cannot completely ignore the role politics play \nin shaping philosophical thought. Tosaka Jun, a contemporary critic of \nthe Kyoto School of Philosophy whose critique of hermeneutics forms \nthe subject of this paper, poured a lot of effort into demonstrating this. \nHe argued that much of the thought of the Japanese philosophers of his \ngeneration was informed by an ethnocentrism fueled by the ambitions of \na nationalistic government. When it comes to showing how politics shape \nphilosophy, his scathing attack on the Kyoto School is still relevant today. \nThe lofty ideal of Zen enlightenment, to apply Tosaka’s analysis to the \nmost prominent example, quickly loses its value and becomes wholly vacuous \nif its Japanese proponents are convinced that only they are sensible \nenough to experience it, and are thereby the only ones that have access to \nthe world as it supposedly ‘really is’. The idea of Zen enlightenment may \njust have been redeveloped by Japanese intellectuals specifically in order to \ncombat Western claims to universalism, and to thereby contest the global \npolitical hegemony of the Western powers at the end of the nineteenth \nand the beginning of the twentieth century. If this is true, then comparative \nphilosophers can no longer unproblematically dispose of this concept’s \nethnocentric kernel in order to universalize its application. Instead, philosophers \nin the West need to be cautious of the extent to which concepts \nformulated by thinkers of the Kyoto School have been informed by, to put \nit crudely, a political ideology that encouraged ethnocentric irrationalism.
Author: Dennis Prooi
Language: French
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2523330725
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 1
Related to: 9