Alternative education: Examining the effects of alternative educational approaches on student achievement, academic motivation and engagement in Flemish primary schools
Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: In this dissertation the effects of Flemish alternative primary schools (e.g. Freinet schools, Steiner/Waldorf schools) and alternative educational practices (e.g. experiential education) on students achievement, academic motivation and engagement were examined. Students from both alternative and traditional schools were followed longitudinally (data were collected from kindergarten to grade 7). Students development in achievement, academic motivation and engagement was modelled using multilevel growth curve models. To take into account differences between schools in student intake characteristics, we controlled for gender, SES, initial achievement, etc. Besides the examination of main effects of alternative education, we focused on differential effects in terms of students SES, initial language and initial mathematics achievement. This dissertation provided evidence that alternative schools succeed to a lesser extent in improving students mathematics achievement. While students from alternative and traditional schools have similar levels of mathematics achievement at the beginning of first grade, students in alternative schools show a lower learning gain compared to their peers in traditional schools. This effect was the largest among the initially high-achieving students. Regarding reading fluency, spelling and reading comprehension no evidence was found for differences in learning gain in alternative versus traditional schools. The effects on academic engagement measured both in terms of teacher reports and student self-reports are less clear. Overall the effects are in disfavour of students in alternative schools but they appeared only at the beginning of measurements, were relatively small, or only found among a specific subpopulation of the students. Further, students in alternative schools reported lower levels of both autonomous and controlled motivation for school. These results provide average results for alternative schools, but should be nuanced. First, other studies (e.g. de Bilde et al., 2012) have evidenced differences between alternative schools in terms of pedagogical approach and educational network, as well as differences within these groups. Further, a study on experiential education in kindergarten evidenced that some alternative approaches can be disadvantageous for achievement, especially for initially low-achieving students (e.g., autonomy-supportive teaching style) but that other practices can effectively promote achievement (stimulating teaching style).
Source: Lirias
Author: Jerissa de Bilde
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: alternative education, elementary school, Waldorf schools, experiential education, academic performance, academic motivation, academic engagement, mathematics achievement, reading fluency, socioeconomic status, autonomous motivation, controlled motivation, school choice, longitudinal development
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2524593384
