Work

The relationship between reading comprehension and online inference generation in children

Year: 2002
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis investigated the relationship between on-line inference generation and reading comprehension in children.An initial investigation was conducted in order to assess the degree of inferential ability required to meet the demands of standardised tests of reading comprehension.While all of the tests required some degree of inference generation, the tests varied in the extent to which they required inferences based in realworld knowledge and those that required the use of cohesive devices.Moreover, the tests also varied in the extent to which they required inferences that were necessary for maintaining textual coherence.Children's ability to answer questions that required inferences was related to their reading comprehension ability and those with less well developed comprehension skills performed particularly poorly on inferences requiring the application of real-world knowledge to the information provided in the text.The remainder of this thesis described a series of studies that were conducted using an on-line passage reading and sentence verification task in which children read a series of passages presented on the screen.At the end of each passage, children were required to judge whether a target sentence was true or false, using a key-press response on the computer keyboard.Each target sentence related to specific information embedded in the passage.Three types of test sentence were used; sentences that relayed information explicitly stated in the text, sentences that represented the mediating idea underlying a causal inference required for textual coherence, or sentences that represented a possible elaboration from the text.Off-line comprehension questions relating to the experimental passages and additional measures of cognitive ability were also used.The results presented in Chapters 4,5,6, and 7 indicate that children generate causal inferences but not elaborative inferences on-line during reading.In Chapter 4, evidence is presented to suggest that the same pattern of inference generation is found in texts of both a narrative and expository nature, and thus that text genre does not affect inference generation.Similarly, the results presented in Chapters 5, 6, and 7 suggest that children are able to generate inferences from texts containing information that is inconsistent with real world knowledge.These results are discussed in terms of previous ii research into inference generation, the development of logical reasoning and the belief bias effect.Correlational analyses reveal a consistent relationship between inference generation and reading comprehension throughout this thesis.Moreover, a developmental trend revealed in Chapter 6 suggests that reading skill and not chronological age is important in the development of inferential skills.However, in contrast to previous research, the results presented in Chapter 7 reveal that children with specific comprehension difficulties were able to generate causal inferences on-line.These results suggest that, while performance on the inference generation task clearly depended on reading comprehension skill, other factors also played a role.These results are discussed in terms of possible differences in working memory capacity and levels of strategic processing.
Institution: University of York
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2528991806
Cites: 138
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10