Work

How do visually mediated encounters differ from traditional interviews?

Year: 2009
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: Increasing interest in visual research methods within the social sciences reflects an expansion beyond those disciplines where they were initially developed (Banks, 2001; Prosser, 1998). In education this increased interest is clear, but it remains necessary to demonstrate to researchers, and their funders, that visual methods can add to, or replace, traditional research tools, such as interviews. Research has been carried out in educational settings using various visually-based activities to mediate interviews. These methods are usually judged to produce different information from that collected through traditional interviewing. For example, Bragg and Buckingham (2008) comment on teenagers creating scrapbooks that “the method gave us access to a wider range of voices than might have been obtained through interview alone” (p.121). Although Bragg and Buckingham do not argue that “any version of the self our participants presented was more authentic than any other”, we question whether the emergence of different information suggests that in certain situations visual methods might be more appropriate than traditional interviewing. We will examine the use that we, and other researchers, have made of visually mediated encounters. Our research has included participants ranging in age from children to younger adults and adults, and has provided data about a wide range of issues, including experience of the school learning environment, the ethos of a school and attitudes to a student professional placement. We will consider the potential of these methods to be more inclusive and empowering of participants; to generate novel ideas and as part of an iterative pattern of research.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2529603894
FWCI: 6.103
Cites: 18
Cited by: 16
Related to: 10