Work

Towards guidelines for error message design in digital systems

Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: A part of many digital system is the display of error messages. The research aims to create\na set of guidelines for error message design in digital systems. These guidelines will enable\ndesigners and developers to create better error messages that convey the right information\nat the right time and in the right way. In other words, to create error messages that are\nnecessary and effective.\nThe first step in the process of generating this set of guidelines was to perform a literature\nreview in order to find existing theory that is applicable to the design of error messages. The\nliterature review also includes research on warning design theory. The assumption is that\nwarnings are, to some extent, similar to error messages. Therefore, the research surrounding\nit is also expected to be applicable to error messages. The use of warning design theory\nstems from the lack of research on error messages and the comparable richness of the body\nof knowledge on warnings.\nFrom this literature review it was possible to propose a set of guidelines for error message\ndesign. The initially proposed guidelines were evaluated by performing two usability studies\non an existing Internet banking website. The first usability study involved a heuristic evaluation\nof some of the error messages in the website, using the guidelines as heuristics. The\nsecond usability study entailed conducting individual interviews with representative users\nwhere the same error messages used in the heuristic evaluation was evaluated.\nThe results of the heuristic evaluation were then used to determine whether the guidelines\nare effective. The effectiveness of a guideline is an indication of whether experts can easily\nuse it to analyse error messages and detect possible usability problems. The results of\nthe individual interviews were used to determine whether the proposed guidelines are valid.\nThe validity of the guidelines is a measure of how well the guidelines and the suggestions\nraised by using them, reflect the pain points and concerns of users. The results of both\nthese usability studies were also compared to one another to get a further indication of the\neffectiveness and validity of the guidelines.\nFrom this analysis some changes and additions were made to the initially proposed guidelines.\nThese updates are expected to increase the effectiveness and validity of the guidelines\ncompared to the initially proposed guidelines. In other words, the updates are expected to make the guidelines easier to use and to enable experts to find usability problems that are a\ncloser match to the concerns of users.\nThe research followed the design science research methodology, but only completing one\niteration of the process. Subsequent iterations that will further refine the proposed guidelines\nis left for future research.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2541217657
Cites: 59
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10