Work

Effectiveness of a Typical-Person Heuristic for the Prediction of Conformity Behavior

Year: 2012
Type: article
Abstract: Conformity studies using an Asch’s (1952, 1956) line judgment task have inevitably deceived participants and incurred serious ethical problems. In the present study, a videotaped unanimous group-pressure situation of Furukawa, Ban, Hoshi, and Tabata’s (1986) conformity experiment was used to find unobtrusive alternatives to deception. Provided with full explanations of the true purpose and adopted deceptions of the real conformity experiment, participants in a typical-person heuristic condition were requested to imagine and answer with the responses a typical student of their university would give in this situation. Participants in a role playing condition were requested to answer with the responses they would give as if they were actual participants in this situation. As a control group, participants in a simple video-simulation condition were requested to answer with the responses they would give without any information about the true purpose and adopted deceptions. The mean of error responses was higher in the typical-person heuristic condition than either in the role playing or in the simple video-simulation condition. The ratio of error responses given by the typical-person heuristic group was identical to the ratio reported in Furukawa et al. (1986) and almost identical to the ratio reported in Asch (1956, Experiment 1). These findings
Author: Haruki Sakai
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2551165409
FWCI:
Cites: 16
Cited by:
Related to: 10