Work

An ethic of care in the dialogical space : what do NGOs learn from their conversations with states? : case studies from Scotland and Zambia

Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The increase in the presence and influence of Non-Governmental Organisations \n(NGOs) locally and internationally is having a noticeable effect on the policy process at a \nnational level. While the NGO sector is more commonly examined at an international level, \nits impact at the state and sub-state level remains unexplored. This gap in the literature is \naddressed as a primary problem in this thesis. By exploring the relationship between the \nNGO and the state, the significance of this relationship is emphasised as a necessary \ninclusion in International Relations literature. \nThe NGO sector presents civil society with a road into, and in some cases an \nalternative to, traditional modes of political advocacy. This increases civil society’s ability to \nimpact the policy process by creating, what is identified in this thesis as, a dialogical space. \nThe dialogical space allows for an exchange of ideas and thus influences the decision-making \nprocess of the state, if and when it is explored. Furthermore, the dialogical space facilitates, \nas is shown here, learning through the conversations that take place between NGOs and the \nstate. This thesis asks ‘what do NGOs learn from their conversations with states?’ and \npresents the ‘lessons learned’ from Scottish and Zambian case studies. \nNGOs are identified here as civil society in organisation and have a particular \nrelationship with the communities they represent. This relationship is empirically examined \nand presented here in the Scottish and Zambian case studies. This thesis examines the \nrelationship between the NGO and civil society, and most importantly the relationship \nbetween the NGO and the state using the ethic of care as a theoretical lens. Conclusions are drawn from the interviews conducted during the fieldwork. The ethic of care is located in \npractice and used as a theoretical lens to examine what the local NGOs learn from their \ninteractions with the state. Both case studies confirm that an ethic of care is a prevalent \nethic in NGO practice, as identified by the NGO workers interviewed. Furthermore, when \nused as an analytical lens the ethic of care is shown to be used as a tool by NGOs to nurture \nan ethic of care in statesmanship. \nThe thesis specifically highlights that NGOs have learned from their conversations \nwith states and that, through the creation and use of the dialogical space, an ethic of care in \npractice can be traced. The greater significance of this thesis is that it addresses the \nrelationship between the NGO and the state at a local and national level; a topic which is \nlacking in current IR literature, despite being of crucial value for understanding the state’s \ninteraction with non-state actors, in this case local NGOs. Furthermore, through the use of \nthe ethic of care both as an exploratory lens and in its identification as a practical ethic, this \nthesis highlights the importance of an ethic of care in theory and practice.
Author: Ashley Cole
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2559058987
Cites: 94
Cited by:
Related to: 10